Refine Search
Map
Sort by
3060 County Highway 11, Hartwick
$379,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1684412 MLS
Completely renovated and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of historic charm and modern convenience. Built in 1890 and situated on 0.84 acres in the Cooperstown School District, the property features 1,908 square feet of living space, a full usable basement, and a large two-story barn/shop ideal for storage, hobbies, or workshop space. Extensive renovations include updated electrical and plumbing systems, improved insulation, drywall, flooring, lighting, doors, trim, and hardware throughout. The floor plan was redesigned to improve functionality with a new staircase, reconfigured second-floor layout, added bedroom closets, and a beautifully remodeled bathroom. The home features a sunroom, laundry room, bonus room, walk-in closet, gas range, and oil-fired forced-air heat. Waterproof luxury vinyl flooring runs throughout the main living areas, with carpeting in the bedrooms. The basement has been significantly upgraded with concrete floors, spray-foam insulation, updated utilities, a new oil tank, and serviced mechanicals. Outside, both the home and barn have been freshly painted, the stone foundation repaired, the Bilco entry rebuilt, and porch and deck improvements completed. Durable metal roofs cover both structures. Located in the hamlet of Hartwick, you'll enjoy the charm of a close-knit community with a library, café, diner, post office, local shops, playground, and convenient services nearby. Otsego Creek borders the property and is stocked annually for fishing, while Cooperstown and Oneonta are just a short drive away. With the major renovations already completed, there's nothing left to do but move in, relax, and dip your toes in the creek.

3060 County Highway 11, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014
335 Hoke Rd, Fly Creek
$399,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11780528 MLS
c.1840 Fly Creek Farmhouse, ±6.981 Surveyed Acres This vernacular farmhouse on Hoke Road has been cared for by the same family for more than 70 years, set on ±6.981 surveyed acres of rolling Otsego County countryside with long valley views. It offers ±1,952 square feet across two full floors. The main level opens into a generous eat-in kitchen with a tin ceiling and abundant cabinetry, an adjacent mudroom-laundry, spacious living room, dining room with tin ceiling, first-floor bedroom, full bath, and a welcoming foyer. Upstairs, four additional bedrooms and full hall bath provide space for family and guests. A covered front porch facing perennial gardens, stone walls, and the valley views beyond. The nearly seven-acre lot delivers real privacy - the kind that's hard to find on a smaller parcel - while staying just minutes from Cooperstown: the Glimmerglass Festival, Otsego Golf Course, the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, Clark Sports Center, the Otesaga Resort Hotel, Leatherstocking Golf Course, and Brewery Ommegang are all close at hand. 5 BR | 2 BA | ±1,952 SF | ±6.981 Acres | c.1840 Farmhouse | Eat-In Kitchen | Tin Ceiling | Mudroom-Laundry | Covered Front Porch | Perennial Gardens | Stone Walls | Valley Views | Minutes to Cooperstown **More land available - ±38 acres. See MLS: 11905630

335 Hoke Rd, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Patricia Bensen-Ashley with ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY
Lot 12.32 County Highway 31, Middlefield
$245,000
R1678180 MLS
High above the northern reaches of Otsego Lake, this remarkable 18.59-acre parcel offers something increasingly difficult to find: a private homesite with sweeping views across one of New York's most iconic lakes. From the established building site, expansive views unfold across Hyde Bay and Peggs Point toward Hyde Hall and Glimmerglass State Park. Sunlight dances across the water below while the ever-changing seasons continually reshape the landscape in a way that never grows old. It is easy to understand why James Fenimore Cooper immortalized these waters as "Glimmerglass," inspired by the lake's shimmering, reflective beauty. The groundwork for your vision is already underway. An established driveway entrance with engineered drainage improvements leads to a partially cleared building envelope, thoughtfully positioned to capture the lake views while maintaining privacy and a sense of retreat. Beyond the homesite, the property rises into a beautiful expanse of mature woodland. Natural contours lead uphill through the forest before leveling into an upper section of peaceful woods, inviting exploration, hiking, and upland recreational pursuits. The combination of elevated lake views, wooded acreage, and privacy creates a unique balance. The location places you within easy reach of everything that makes the Cooperstown region so desirable. The Village of Cooperstown, home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, boutique shopping, restaurants, breweries, and cultural attractions, is just a short drive away. The area's renowned youth baseball tournaments generate consistent demand for seasonal accommodations, creating possibilities for those considering a future investment-oriented build. Properties with views of Otsego Lake rarely become available, and opportunities to build a custom home overlooking these historic waters are even more uncommon. Whether you envision a personal retreat, a legacy property to be enjoyed for generations, or an investment in one of upstate New York's most sought-after destinations, this offering captures the natural beauty, history, and enduring appeal that have drawn people to Glimmerglass Country for centuries.

Lot 12.32 County Highway 31, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-222-6867
108 Toy Farm Road, Hartwick
$219,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1684497 MLS
Nestled on 1.74 beautiful acres with breathtaking views, this very nice Ranch-style double wide in the quaint town of Hartwick, New York offers the privacy and seclusion you've been searching for. Conveniently located between Oneonta and Cooperstown and in the Cooperstown School District. This Three Bedroom, two bath home has been tastefully updated with BRAND NEW FLOORING throughout the entire interior, creating a fresh and inviting feel the moment you step inside. Enjoy an eat-in kitchen, CENTRAL AC for comfort during the warm summer months, Gas Fireplace in the Living Room, and a wraparound deck perfect for relaxing while taking in the peaceful setting. The oversized detached TWO-CAR Garage offers exceptional additional space and could accommodate up to Four Vehicles. Also, it is ideal for equipment, storage, hobbies, or all your outdoor accessories. A Blacktop driveway, plenty of parking, Affordable Taxes, and a location close to Historic Cooperstown make this property an incredible opportunity. Perfect as a Primary home or for snowbirds who want to come back in the summer. Looking for an investment opportunity? This could also be a nice baseball airbnb. This property is not to be missed.

108 Toy Farm Road, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna. Contact: 607-434-7436
7667 State Highway 80, Springfield Center
$359,000
11 Beds ⋅ 11 Baths ⋅ 11778038 MLS
The Hayden Creek Inn offers a rare opportunity to acquire a fully operational bed-and-breakfast with 10 bedrooms - each with private baths, and a 1 bedroom apartment for owner's use or expanded suite set-up. Located in the heart of Central New York's scenic countryside, just moments from Cooperstown and its year-round tourism economy, in the charming hamlet of Springfield Center, the property integrates its rich history and timeless hospitality appeal with the growing demand for destination lodging and experiential travel. A long time favorite for Glimmerglass Opera Guests, and those who wish to escape the crowds of Cooperstown, yet within close driving distance, investors and entrepreneurs will appreciate the inn's established use, flexible layout, and potential for expanded revenue through events, retreats, farm-to-table dining, or boutique hospitality concepts. The property's inviting atmosphere and classic architecture create the kind of memorable guest experience that drives repeat bookings and strong word-of-mouth marketing. With increasing interest in independently owned inns and lifestyle businesses, the Hayden Creek Inn presents both a sound investment and an opportunity to build a meaningful hospitality brand. Whether envisioned as a refined country inn, wellness retreat, hybrid live/work venture, or spacious family home, the possibilities are as compelling as the setting itself. For buyers seeking a distinctive property with charm, visibility, and income potential, the Hayden Creek Inn stands apart. While the inn could benefit from a little TLC and cosmetic updating, its solid bones, idyllic location, and well-loved history make it a rare opportunity to restore and reimagine a true creekside gem.

7667 State Highway 80, Springfield Center

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC
4983 State Highway 28, Cooperstown
$1,500,000
10 Beds ⋅ 8.5 Baths ⋅ 11363531 MLS
INCOME-GENERATING INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY - Prime Cooperstown Location on State Highway 28! Welcome to the Hope Mill property portfolio, a rare, fully operational, and highly successful investment opportunity in the heart of Cooperstown, NY. Set on approximately 5 scenic acres bordering picturesque Oaks Creek, this turnkey business includes three established and professionally managed rental homes, a heated in-ground saltwater pool, and an unmatched location between the Village of Cooperstown and Cooperstown Dreams Park. This rare multi-home compound consists of the historic stone Hope Mill House, the charming Hope Mill Cottage, and the spacious Hope Mill Ranch. Together, the properties are currently operating as highly successful short-term summer baseball rentals with strong demand and summer 2026 bookings already secured, generating over $140,000 in projected revenue. The established booking history and repeat rental demand highlight the strength and stability of this proven income-producing portfolio. In total, the three homes offer 10 bedrooms and 8.5 bathrooms, providing exceptional flexibility for large groups, tournament families, vacation rentals, and extended-stay guests. Each residence is thoughtfully positioned to offer privacy while still benefiting from shared access to the beautifully maintained grounds and resort-style heated saltwater pool. In addition to its strong summer performance, the property has a proven history of both short-term and long-term rentals, offering clear expansion potential for year-round income optimization. Opportunities exist to further increase revenue through extended seasonality, rate adjustments, and additional use strategies, making this a scalable hospitality investment. Ideally located just 3.2 miles from the Village of Cooperstown, the property provides convenient access to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Bassett Medical Center, shopping, dining, breweries, and all local attractions. Cooperstown Dreams Park is only minutes away, making this one of the most desirable rental locations for baseball families and tournament visitors. The property also sits directly on the public bus line, offering easy transportation to both Cooperstown and Oneonta. Whether you are seeking a fully operational income-producing business, a rare multi-home compound investment, or a legacy property with strong upside potential, the opportunities here are exceptional. Schedule your private showing today!

4983 State Highway 28, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Natasha Selover with Stack-Page Properties
7667 State Highway 80, Springfield
$359,000
R1683138 MLS
The Hayden Creek Inn offers a rare opportunity to acquire a fully operational bed-and-breakfast with 10 bedrooms - each with private baths, and a 1 bedroom apartment for owner's use or expanded suite set-up. Located in the heart of Central New York’s scenic countryside, just moments from Cooperstown and its year-round tourism economy, in the charming hamlet of Springfield Center, the property integrates its rich history and timeless hospitality appeal with the growing demand for destination lodging and experiential travel. A long time favorite for Glimmerglass Opera Guests, and those who wish to escape the crowds of Cooperstown, yet within close driving distance, investors and entrepreneurs will appreciate the inn’s established use, flexible layout, and potential for expanded revenue through events, retreats, farm-to-table dining, or boutique hospitality concepts. The property’s inviting atmosphere and classic architecture create the kind of memorable guest experience that drives repeat bookings and strong word-of-mouth marketing. With increasing interest in independently owned inns and lifestyle businesses, the Hayden Creek Inn presents both a sound investment and an opportunity to build a meaningful hospitality brand. Whether envisioned as a refined country inn, wellness retreat, hybrid live/work venture, or spacious family home, the possibilities are as compelling as the setting itself. For buyers seeking a distinctive property with charm, visibility, and income potential, the Hayden Creek Inn stands apart. While the inn could benefit from a little TLC and cosmetic updating, its solid bones, idyllic location, and well-loved history make it a rare opportunity to restore and reimagine a true creekside gem.

7667 State Highway 80, Springfield

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

7667 State Highway 80, Springfield
$359,000
11 Beds ⋅ 11 Baths ⋅ R1680094 MLS
The Hayden Creek Inn offers a rare opportunity to acquire a fully operational bed-and-breakfast with 10 bedrooms - each with private baths, and a 1 bedroom apartment for owner's use or expanded suite set-up. Located in the heart of Central New York’s scenic countryside, just moments from Cooperstown and its year-round tourism economy, in the charming hamlet of Springfield Center, the property integrates its rich history and timeless hospitality appeal with the growing demand for destination lodging and experiential travel. A long time favorite for Glimmerglass Opera Guests, and those who wish to escape the crowds of Cooperstown, yet within close driving distance, investors and entrepreneurs will appreciate the inn’s established use, flexible layout, and potential for expanded revenue through events, retreats, farm-to-table dining, or boutique hospitality concepts. The property’s inviting atmosphere and classic architecture create the kind of memorable guest experience that drives repeat bookings and strong word-of-mouth marketing. With increasing interest in independently owned inns and lifestyle businesses, the Hayden Creek Inn presents both a sound investment and an opportunity to build a meaningful hospitality brand. Whether envisioned as a refined country inn, wellness retreat, hybrid live/work venture, or spacious family home, the possibilities are as compelling as the setting itself. For buyers seeking a distinctive property with charm, visibility, and income potential, the Hayden Creek Inn stands apart. While the inn could benefit from a little TLC and cosmetic updating, its solid bones, idyllic location, and well-loved history make it a rare opportunity to restore and reimagine a true creekside gem.

7667 State Highway 80, Springfield

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

6213 State Highway 28, Fly Creek
$235,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 11742570 MLS
Charming c.1880 cottage in the heart of Fly Creek - move-in ready, loaded with character, and just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown. 3 bed | 1 bath | ±1,534 sq ft | steel roof | detached two-car carriage barn with loft | This wonderfully preserved and updated cottage sits at the historic four corners of Fly Creek, offering the kind of warmth, detail, and quiet village setting. The main floor delivers a generous eat-in kitchen, a mudroom-laundry, a comfortable living or dining room, and a handsome den with built-in bookcases - all flowing over hardwood and tile floors. The high-end tiled bathroom with jetted tub and glass-enclosed shower feels like a genuine splurge. Upstairs, wide-plank pine floors lead to a spacious primary bedroom with walk-in closet, plus a flexible eaves room ideal for a home office or guest space. Outside: a cozy covered front porch, a large backyard, and a two-car carriage barn with walk-up loft storage - a ready-made workshop, studio, or home occupation space. Steel roof, and replacement windows throughout for peace of mind. Cooperstown Central School District. High-speed internet. Easy access to US 20, I-88, and the NYS Thruway - approximately 3.5 hours to New York City. Walk, bike, or drive minutes to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Otsego Lake, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, Glimmerglass Festival, Brewery Ommegang, Cooperstown Dreams Park, and the shops and restaurants of the Village of Cooperstown.

6213 State Highway 28, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Patricia Bensen-Ashley with ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY
25 Railroad Ave, Cooperstown
$520,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 11738924 MLS
Located in the revitalized Railroad Avenue corridor of the Village of Cooperstown, this distinctive 3-4-bedroom Italianate, built in 1880, offers rare flexibility with commercial zoning and the potential for single- or two-family living (special permit required). Set on a deep 0.33-acre lot, the property provides ample space for a carriage barn, gardens, and off-street parking, with additional parking behind the building. Inside, a gracious staircase welcomes you at the front entry, complemented by original wood floors, classic woodwork, and an updated kitchen. The covered front porch enhances the home's timeless curb appeal, while the surrounding neighborhood blends thoughtfully restored storefronts, professional offices, apartments, and residences, creating a vibrant village setting. Meticulously maintained, the EXTERIOR WAS SANDED AND FRESHLY PAINTED IN AUGUST 2026, ENHANCING THE PROPERTY'S APPEARANCE. The property has also benefited from numerous improvements, including a paved driveway and parking area (2014-2015), new doors and storm windows (2015), a completely new roof (2016), masonry restoration (2018), and new flooring (2022). Currently configured as professional office space, the property presents an attractive investment opportunity. Existing tenancies generate $1,850 in monthly rental income, with the owner currently occupying approximately one-half of the available space. Whether you continue its commercial use, establish a live/work environment, or explore its residential possibilities, this property offers exceptional flexibility. Just two blocks from Main Street and within easy walking distance of Otsego Lake, Bassett Medical Center, schools, restaurants, boutique shopping, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, this remarkable property offers an exceptional opportunity to own a well-maintained historic building in one of Cooperstown's most desirable and evolving locations-perfect for investment, business, or creating a distinctive village residence.

25 Railroad Ave, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Denise Page-LaCava with Stack-Page Properties
383 County Highway 45, Hartwick
$799,000
8 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1676915 MLS
Opportunity meets versatility at 383 County Highway 45, between Hartwick and Milford area, minutes to Cooperstown. Ideally positioned to capture demand from both the Cooperstown and Oneonta baseball destinations, this property has an established history as a successful short-term rental with strong seasonal appeal. Set in a peaceful country setting, the property offers the space, comfort, and flexibility today’s buyers are looking for. The layout easily accommodates larger groups, making it well-suited for continued rental use, while also providing the functionality and warmth of a full-time residence for those seeking a primary or second home. Included in the offering is an additional parcel of just under three acres, creating even more opportunity. What truly sets this property apart is its location. Convenient to both Cooperstown and Oneonta, it offers access to two major summer destinations while maintaining the privacy and tranquility of a country retreat. This balance makes it especially appealing to both homeowners and those exploring income-producing possibilities. Whether you are looking to expand your real estate portfolio or settle into a property with flexible use options, this offering presents a unique opportunity in a highly sought-after region.

383 County Highway 45, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014
1094 County Highway 33, Cooperstown
$395,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11737527 MLS
(9745) Just 3 miles from Cooperstown sited on a country lane. Updated 3BR/2BA home with large Living room, formal Dining room, Kitchen includes cherry cabinets, granite countertops, Induction range, fully applianced. Family room with gas stove and skylight. Study/Work area. Washer & Dryer, Hardwood floors, carpeted bedrooms. Wrap-around front porch, Newly renovated, rebuilt, and painted wraparound front porch. Side porch, newer roof, newer hot water furnace. electric heat upstairs. Newly renovated wrap-a-round porch. Nicely landscaped, large lawn with raised-bed gardens. 2 car detached garage. High speed internet available. Just 5 minutes to Bassett Hospital and Clark Sports Center/Gymnasium. Relax in this renovated 1898 Eye-brow Colonial. Cooperstown Schools. Hubbell's Exclusive.

1094 County Highway 33, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Cindy Hubbell with HUBBELLS REAL ESTATE INC
6225 State Highway 28, Otsego
$410,000
R1674237 MLS
Prime, high-visibility corner location on New York State Route 28 in Fly Creek—one of the main corridors directly leading into Cooperstown, just minutes away. This turnkey commercial garage is well-suited for automotive, mechanical, or service-based use, with flexible interior space that can be adapted to office, detailing, or a wide range of commercial applications. Positioned along a well-traveled route with consistent local and seasonal traffic heading into Cooperstown, the property benefits from strong visibility and ongoing demand driven by the area’s tourism and regional activity. With solid road frontage, paved parking, and room for expansion, this asset offers both immediate functionality and long-term potential. A compelling opportunity for investors or owner-operators to capitalize on location, exposure, and flexibility—whether continuing its current use or repositioning the space to align with future growth.

6225 State Highway 28, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna. Contact: 315-395-1849
276 Van Yahres Road, Cooperstown
$1,295,000
7 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 11678313 MLS
Discover a rare Cooperstown Lake View treasure on 11+ private acres, located on the east side of Otsego Lake, where rolling hills meet shimmering waters. This remarkable two-home estate, a thriving seasonal B&B from 2001-2023, plus two summers of Dreams Park Rentals and Airbnb, offers unparalleled versatility as a luxury rental property, family retreat, or private residence. The original home, built in 1988 with pine and oak floors, features 5 bedrooms, including a first-floor suite, an open kitchen, a large dining area with floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the lake, and an inviting living room with a wood-burning fireplace. This home is heated with electric baseboard heat, providing cozy comfort throughout. The 2010 log-faced addition has radiant floor heating throughout, central AC, and a geothermal system; two bedrooms with en-suite bathrooms that include jacuzzi tubs; French doors that lead to private decks; and a view of the lake. A loft, currently used as a home office, overlooks the open living room, which features a striking stone wood-burning fireplace and a gourmet kitchen. Cherry hardwood floors, a stunning antler chandelier, a Tiffany-style stairway chandelier, Tiffany fixtures, and 6 ceiling fans add warmth and character throughout. The two homes are conveniently connected, creating a seamless flow between the original residence and the addition. Finished basements in both homes include bonus rooms ideal for offices or fitness areas, additional sleeping space, and a full kitchenette in the addition. 6 of the 7 bedrooms boast a private bath, with propane fireplaces in all but one, providing convenient, instant warmth and a cozy ambiance. Almost all bedrooms have balconies overlooking the lake, ensuring every guest or family member enjoys serene views and comfort. A whole-house generator and high-speed internet enhance everyday convenience. Expansive windows and a skylight fill the home with abundant natural light, enhancing the warmth and beauty of the interior spaces. The property features 3 Jacuzzi tubs plus one 2-person soaking tub, two ponds, walking trails, a potting shed, a garden shed, a carport, and a two-car garage. Sunsets over the lake, framed by surrounding hills, create a daily spectacle that can be enjoyed from multiple balconies or quiet corners of the estate. Just minutes from the Historic Village of Cooperstown and the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, residents enjoy charming shops, fine dining, and cultural attractions, while the estate itself offers privacy and the peaceful rhythm of lakeside living. The scenic fairways of Leatherstocking Golf Course trace the lake's edge, while the Fenimore Art Museum and the acclaimed Glimmerglass Festival enrich the area's cultural landscape. Glimmerglass State Park offers hiking trails, bike paths, fishing, picnic areas, a beach, and seasonal events. With expansive acreage, breathtaking vistas, and exceptional interior features, this property presents a rare opportunity to own a piece of Cooperstown's most coveted lifestyle, where every day feels like a retreat. Lovingly cared for and meticulously maintained, this exceptional property is ready for its next owner to enjoy, appreciate, and create lasting memories. A 3D tour and video are available on our website.

276 Van Yahres Road, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Denise Page-LaCava with Stack-Page Properties
533 Glimmerglen Road, Otsego
$460,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1670321 MLS
Huge Price Improvement, Minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame and nestled in the heart of Cooperstown's Glimmerglass region, 533 Glimmerglen Road is a rare find: a 1999-built Cape Cod on 1.79 acres with the curb appeal of a boutique country estate and the flexibility to serve as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or high-performing short-term rental in one of upstate New York's strongest tourism markets. Cooperstown draws hundreds of thousands of visitors annually to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Ommegang Brewery, Glimmerglass Opera, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, and Otsego Lake. Quality rental inventory in this radius is consistently tight, and properties with this kind of presentation rarely come available. Inside, the layout rewards flexibility. A primary suite and second bedroom on the main floor provide true single-level living, while the second floor opens additional space for family or guests. Three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms offer comfortable capacity for a household or turnover-ready guest accommodations. The country kitchen and formal dining room feature solid surface counters and gas appliances, designed for real use. Outside, ornamental gardens, flowering beds, and manicured shrubberies create a lush, curated setting that elevates the entire property. The patio and porch invite you to settle into the Otsego County countryside. For hobbyists, craftsmen, or collectors, this property stands alone: two heated, detached two-car garages with dedicated shop space provide four total bays for vehicles, tools, and projects. Two miles to the Otesaga Golf Course. Three miles to the historic Otesaga Hotel. Eight miles to the renowned Glimmerglass Theater. Offered as-is, this is a solid foundation with serious long-term upside in a market that continues to reward well-positioned properties. Your Cooperstown chapter starts here.

533 Glimmerglen Road, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Charlotteville Realty, LLC. Contact: 607-282-6242
533 Glimmerglen Rd, Cooperstown
$460,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 11683372 MLS
Huge Price Improvement, Minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame and nestled in the heart of Cooperstown's Glimmerglass region, 533 Glimmerglen Road is a rare find: a 1999-built Cape Cod on 1.79 acres with the curb appeal of a boutique country estate and the flexibility to serve as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or high-performing short-term rental in one of upstate New York's strongest tourism markets. Cooperstown draws hundreds of thousands of visitors annually to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Ommegang Brewery, Glimmerglass Opera, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, and Otsego Lake. Quality rental inventory in this radius is consistently tight, and properties with this kind of presentation rarely come available. Inside, the layout rewards flexibility. A primary suite and second bedroom on the main floor provide true single-level living, while the second floor opens additional space for family or guests. Three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms offer comfortable capacity for a household or turnover-ready guest accommodations. The country kitchen and formal dining room feature solid surface counters and gas appliances, designed for real use. Outside, ornamental gardens, flowering beds, and manicured shrubberies create a lush, curated setting that elevates the entire property. The patio and porch invite you to settle into the Otsego County countryside. For hobbyists, craftsmen, or collectors, this property stands alone: two heated, detached two-car garages with dedicated shop space provide four total bays for vehicles, tools, and projects. Two miles to the Otesaga Golf Course. Three miles to the historic Otesaga Hotel. Eight miles to the renowned Glimmerglass Theater. Offered as-is, this is a solid foundation with serious long-term upside in a market that continues to reward well-positioned properties. Your Cooperstown chapter starts here.

533 Glimmerglen Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Kevin Lucero with CHARLOTTEVILLE REALTY
0 Keating Road, Fly Creek
$89,000
11679819 MLS
Ideally located on a very quiet town maintained road only 6.5 miles outside the historic Village of Cooperstown, this lot is just waiting for your building plans. The 11.78 acres are predominantly wooded with a mix of hardwoods and hemlock, for a potential future return on investment. There is approximately 875 feet of road frontage, with power and high speed internet access, providing lots of options for building. There are wetlands located on the back corner of the parcel. The rear property line borders a significant wetland area along Oaks Creek, providing habitat for abundant wildlife and helping protect the natural surroundings from future development. Located within the Cooperstown School District, and a 10 minute drive to world class museums, restaurants, beautiful Otsego Lake, and all your necessities, making this a must see!

0 Keating Road, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Mike Burns with Stack-Page Properties
L 8.06 Thayer Rd, Hartwick
$33,000
11678261 MLS
± 5.01 acre lot in the Apple Blossom Farm subdivision - partially wooded, stream and wetlands, with ±420' of road frontage. Electric service, and internet available from Otsego Electric Cooperative / OEConnect. Thayer road is a quiet and peaceful, a perfect place to build your new home. Edmeston Central School. Deed restrictions apply. Easy access to US 20, Glimmerglass Festival, Cooperstown, Otsego Lake. Easy drive to Oneonta, Albany, Utica. 3.5 hours to NYC.

L 8.06 Thayer Rd, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Patricia Bensen-Ashley with ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY
6208 State Highway 28, Otsego
$850,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1666125 MLS
Welcome to 6208 NY-28 in Fly Creek — a rare mixed-use investment opportunity that perfectly blends small-town charm, modern updates, and immediate business potential. Ideally located just minutes from Cooperstown and the renowned Fly Creek Cider Mill, this highly visible corner property sits in the heart of the hamlet, offering outstanding exposure for business and convenience for residents alike. This impressive building features two commercial spaces and four residential rental units, creating multiple income streams under one roof. The anchor commercial space is currently configured as a fully equipped restaurant and bar, featuring an elegant dining room with tall ceilings, hardwood floors, and large windows that fill the space with natural light. A professional kitchen, handcrafted bar, and outdoor deck create the perfect setting for indoor and seasonal dining. The restaurant space is ready for its next chapter, offering an opportunity for an operator to step in and bring their concept to life quickly. Ownership is open to assisting during the transition to help ensure a smooth start for the next steward of this well-known local establishment. Adjacent to the restaurant is a second commercial storefront currently operating as a consignment shop. With its own entrance, display windows, and flexible layout, this space offers excellent potential for retail, office, gallery, or studio use. Upstairs are four spacious residential apartments, each well maintained with updated kitchens and baths, comfortable living areas, and private entrances. These units provide consistent rental income and strong occupancy history, creating reliable cash flow to complement the commercial spaces below. Additional highlights include ample parking, updated mechanical systems, and a beautifully restored exterior that reflects the timeless character of Fly Creek. The property also features scenic rear views and a generous lot with open green space. Motivated seller - with multiple income streams and a business-ready restaurant space, this property presents a compelling opportunity for investors or entrepreneurs alike.

6208 State Highway 28, Otsego

Listing courtesy of River Hills Properties LLC Lf. Contact:

120 Main Street, Cherry Valley
$549,000
2 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ R1665690 MLS
Historic Splendor Meets Modern Potential: The Tryon Inn Own a piece of American history where the charm of the 18th century meets the limitless potential of your future. The Tryon Inn, a beloved landmark in the historic village of Cherry Valley, is now available for the visionary homeowner. Whether you’re seeking a sprawling family estate, a multi-generational compound, or a sophisticated "live-work" lifestyle, this property offers a canvas of character. The Main Residence: A Grand Colonial Revival Currently operating as a restaurant and tavern, the main building has the architectural heritage that could transition into a luxurious primary home. Expansive rooms with high ceilings, original woodwork, and classic hearth offer a warmth that modern builds simply cannot replicate. The professional-grade kitchen and spacious dining areas provide the ultimate foundation for hosting unforgettable gatherings. Retain the iconic barroom as a home bar and entertaining space. The Historic Guest House: 13 Rooms of Opportunity Situated steps away is the historic 13-room Inn building. While requiring renovations to reach its full potential, this structure is a goldmine of flexibility: An Income-Producing Adjunct: Perfect for high-end boutique lodging or long-term rentals in a high-demand area. Private Guest Wing: Create a dedicated space for extended family, an artist’s colony, or a comprehensive home office complex. The estate is set on 4 pristine acres of lush lawn, framed century-old maple trees. Outdoor Living: Plenty of room for a swimming pool, tennis courts, or formal English gardens. Village Charm: in the heart of historic Cherry Valley. Cooperstown (15 mins): World-class culture, dining, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame are just down the road. Albany (1 hour): An easy commute to the state capital and international airport. Nature & Recreation: Close proximity to Otsego Lake and Glimmerglass State Park. Agent’s Note: This is more than a property; it is a legacy. Meticulously maintained and steeped in local lore, The Tryon Inn is ready for its next chapter as one of the region’s most prestigious private addresses.

120 Main Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

6 Westridge Road, Otsego
$998,000
8 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ R1662979 MLS
Bryn Brooke Manor — an 1884 American Shingle Style estate designed by acclaimed NYC architects Babb, Cook & Willard for Dr. Robert McKim — sits on nearly 3 acres overlooking Otsego Lake in the heart of Cooperstown. Architectural historian Richard G. Wilson called it one of the finest examples of the Shingle Style country house he had ever seen. From the wraparound porches and two-story turret, views stretch across the lake to the Otesaga Hotel and Leatherstocking Golf Course. The Fenimore Art Museum, Farmers’ Museum, Baseball Hall of Fame, and Main Street’s shops and cafés are all a short walk away. Inside, 70+ windows fill the home with light across butternut, oak, and maple finishes. Five fireplaces anchor the main living spaces, and original details — the split staircase, carved entrance door, turret library — remain intact and beautifully maintained. The 400+ sq. ft. chef’s kitchen offers multiple workspaces, a gas cooktop, and direct porch access for easy entertaining. Operating since 1999 as Bryn Brooke Manor Bed & Breakfast, the home has hosted Baseball Hall of Famers and notable guests during induction weekends, including Bobby Murcer, Moose Skowron, Hank Bauer, and author Roger Kahn. Continue the hospitality business or close the door on the B&B and enjoy all 8 bedrooms, 6 full baths, and 2 half baths — including a private caretaker’s suite with separate entrance — as a private family retreat. Recent upgrades include new furnaces, mini-split heat pumps, a full electrical overhaul, fresh exterior paint, and a newly paved driveway. 6,600+ sq. ft. on 4 levels, 2.97 acres. A rare offering, rarely available with this much original character intact.

6 Westridge Road, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0470
851 County Highway 26, Fly Creek
$369,000
5 Baths ⋅ 11585819 MLS
If you are seeking an investment property in close proximity to the historic Village of Cooperstown, this will be a must-see. Located in the quaint hamlet of Fly Creek, this FIVE UNIT property is only three miles outside Cooperstown and has an excellent rental history. The five unit mix includes one two-bedroom, three one-bedroom units, and one studio. Currently fully occupied with long term tenants, so you can immediately begin generating income! There is ample off street parking for all the units, and a two story barn behind the house for storage. Conveniently steps away from a general store, post office, restaurant, and in the Cooperstown School District.

851 County Highway 26, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Ryan Burns with Stack-Page Properties
120 Main Street, Cherry Valley
$549,000
2.5 Baths ⋅ 11628779 MLS
The Historic Tryon Inn & Back Door Bar in Cherry Valley, NY: this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to acquire the venerable Tryon Inn, a cornerstone of the charming, historic village of Cherry Valley. More than just a building, this is a turnkey, fully renovated, and well-established business that serves as the beloved social hub of the community and a destination for travelers along scenic Route 20. While historically operating as a tavern, you may have a vision for a brew pub, with loads of parking and indoor and outdoor space for entertainment. Cherry Valley is a community of very involved residents, artists, musicians, teachers, tradespeople and business owners. With an eclectic population and beautiful farming countryside, Cherry Valley is a peaceful town to live and work. Investment Highlights • Turn-Key Business: 129 seat restaurant, plus the lively 34-seat Back Door Bar and the outdoor patio seating for 32 in the warm months. • Large sparkling kitchen is fully equipped, bright and completely up to date. • The current structure, built around 1900 on the site of the original 1780s tavern, is steeped in local history and Colonial Revival charm, attracting history buffs and patrons seeking an authentic upstate experience. • Strategically located on Main Street in the heart of historic Cherry Valley, an area famous for its proximity to Cooperstown (Baseball Hall of Fame, Glimmerglass Opera) and stunning upstate scenery. • Significant Real Estate totaling 5,048 sq ft in the tavern building alone, on a generous 4.25-acre lot, offering ample space and expansion potential. The additional circa 1800 federal style "Inn" building measures an additional 2400 sq ft over two stories. The "Inn" building is freestanding and separate from the turnkey tavern establishment and needs restoration/renovation in order to operate. This is your chance to own a piece of New York state history and step into a successful, cash-flowing business. The Tryon Inn is the definitive social anchor of Cherry Valley, poised for continued success under new ownership. Maintain the beloved local tradition or evolve the concept-the groundwork is laid for your triumph.

120 Main Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC
120 Main Street, Cherry Valley
$549,000
R1656875 MLS
The Historic Tryon Inn & Back Door Bar in Cherry Valley, NY: this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to acquire the venerable Tryon Inn, a cornerstone of the charming, historic village of Cherry Valley. More than just a building, this is a turnkey, fully renovated, and well-established business that serves as the beloved social hub of the community and a destination for travelers along scenic Route 20. While historically operating as a tavern, you may have a vision for a brew pub, with loads of parking and indoor and outdoor space for entertainment. Cherry Valley is a community of very involved residents, artists, musicians, teachers, tradespeople and business owners. With an eclectic population and beautiful farming countryside, Cherry Valley is a peaceful town to live and work. Investment Highlights • Turn-Key Business: 129 seat restaurant, plus the lively 34-seat Back Door Bar and the outdoor patio seating for 32 in the warm months. • Large sparkling kitchen is fully equipped, bright and completely up to date. • The current structure, built around 1900 on the site of the original 1780s tavern, is steeped in local history and Colonial Revival charm, attracting history buffs and patrons seeking an authentic upstate experience. • Strategically located on Main Street in the heart of historic Cherry Valley, an area famous for its proximity to Cooperstown (Baseball Hall of Fame, Glimmerglass Opera) and stunning upstate scenery. • Significant Real Estate totaling 5,048 sq ft in the tavern building alone, on a generous 4.25-acre lot, offering ample space and expansion potential. The additional circa 1800 federal style “Inn” building measures an additional 2400 sq ft over two stories. The “Inn” building is freestanding and separate from the turnkey tavern establishment and needs restoration/renovation in order to operate. This is your chance to own a piece of New York state history and step into a successful, cash-flowing business. The Tryon Inn is the definitive social anchor of Cherry Valley, poised for continued success under new ownership. Maintain the beloved local tradition or evolve the concept—the groundwork is laid for your triumph.

120 Main Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

127 Main Street, Otsego
$599,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1649833 MLS
A rare opportunity awaits in the heart of Cooperstown’s historic business district. Situated just steps from Doubleday Field, 127 Main Street offers over 4,100 square feet of versatile mixed-use space, blending retail, office, and residential components with one-of-a-kind outdoor amenities. The first floor features an inviting office or retail space with wood out of Hyde Hall throughout, and bathroom, ideal for a boutique, professional office, or storefront business. The second floor includes a potential office space that has 3 potential offices with a kitchen area break room and a fully upgraded bathroom! On the third floor, a spacious two-bedroom apartment showcases cathedral ceilings and a private back deck overlooking the courtyard and the historic Doubleday Field, providing a rare and beautiful view in the center of the village. The property is approximately 95% renovated, with extensive updates throughout. Recent improvements include new flooring and paint, updated bathrooms with new toilets and vanities, new water heaters, and modern lighting fixtures, switches, and outlets. Exterior enhancements feature a new fence, iron gates leading from Main Street through a stone pathway that opens into a private backyard courtyard—the only green space within Cooperstown’s business district. The courtyard includes multi-tiered stone patios and a storage shed, offering both functionality and charm. This building presents an exceptional opportunity for owner-occupancy, investment, or mixed-use operations, combining strong street presence with modern updates and classic Cooperstown character. With its prime location, historic charm, and flexible layout, 127 Main Street stands out as one of Cooperstown’s most distinctive and desirable commercial properties!

127 Main Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Glimmerglass Realty Group LLC. Contact: (607) 282-2251
4938 State Highway 28, Hartwick
$915,000
R1655385 MLS
ENTREPRENEURS ALERT: Major opportunity to purchase seasonal restaurant/land/building/equipment: a totally turn-key operation which turns a serious profit over a 14 week summer baseball season, with overlaps of your choice to keep as seasonal or extend as you desire. Rusty Bison is a purpose-built "Team and Group Oriented" location which can accommodate up to three baseball teams at a time, along with regular patrons. Terrific outdoor covered "L-Shaped" patio is 16'X80' for major "outdoor feel"" dining, plus a unique commercial overhead door which auto-opens to bring the outdoors "in" when weather cooperates, along with a second floor loft-style area for private parties or gaming- pool, ping-pong, and darts or simply utilize as overflow seating! Step inside the restaurant to exposed beams and a vaulted ceiling, plus a rustic style 30' wind around bar including hostess station which serves as secondary bar/ overflow area...the decor and atmosphere are the perfect fit at Rusty Bison Restaurant! Handsome wrought iron oversized staircase with bamboo flooring to over 600 sqft of additional seating or gaming space! Spotless 2-line kitchen. Less than 1 mile to Cooperstown Dreams park! Strong seasonal cash flow opportunity!

4938 State Highway 28, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Benson Agency Real Estate LLC. Contact: 607-287-1559
00 Dietsche Road, Cherry Valley
$1,740,000
11620296 MLS
Complete in-woods sap production woodlots sold as a package. Sap can be hauled off site for processing or a sugar house could be built on any of the 10 parcels. Parcels are conveniently located near NY 20 and Interstate 88. Each site has power to the sap sheds and tank storage is at each parcel. Properties have 25,000 taps with 5 collection sites and tree sizes range over 10" and is approximately 80% hard maple and 20% soft maple. The individual sites have a vacuum system drawing toward the road and is efficient set ups! Total of 275.05 acres. Includes sap collection infrastructure affixed to tubing, fittings, pumps, tanks and equipment in pump house.

00 Dietsche Road, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Brent Phetteplace with JUDITH ANN REALTY INC
7715 US Highway 20, Cherry Valley
$99,000
5 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 11598670 MLS
Many updates have been done. Electric service is installed and water is on. Back side of the house has new clapboard siding. Historic Farmhouse with Privacy, Farmland Views & Prime Commercial Exposure - 7715 Route 20, Cherry Valley NY Minutes to Cooperstown and 3 hours to NYC. Own a rare piece of American craftsmanship - a historic farmhouse (circa 1900) built with heavy wood flooring, high ceilings on every floor, and oversized timber framing that stands the test of time. Set along the iconic Route 20 and surrounded by open farmland, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy, rural beauty, and high-visibility commercial opportunity. Property Highlights • Historic Construction (circa 1900): Built with enduring materials, featuring oversized beams and solid framing that exemplify old-world quality. • Spacious Layout: 5 rooms upstairs, 3 rooms downstairs - perfect for living, working, or mixed-use development • Heavy Wood Flooring: Authentic, thick planks throughout every level - strong, beautiful, and full of character. • High Ceilings Everywhere: From the main floor to the attic, tall ceilings enhance openness and light. • Expansive Walk-Up Attic: Full-height, walkable attic ideal for storage, a studio, or future renovation. • Partial Basement: Requires a simple update - a horizontal drain or sump pump. • Solid Timber Construction: Oversized timbers throughout the structure ensure long-lasting strength. Condition and Air Quality A previous leak has been addressed. Setting & Location Set directly on Route 20, this property enjoys maximum exposure to steady highway traffic while maintaining total privacy - there are no immediate neighbors, only peaceful open farmland in every direction. This combination makes it ideal for both living and business - a truly prime advertising location where your sign or business will be seen by countless travelers every day. ️ Commercial & Creative Potential Few properties offer this much versatility. Perfect for: • A restaurant or roadside café • A shop, equipment repair, sales, or storage business • A workshop, studio, or showroom • A high-visibility advertising site - prime exposure right on a major U.S. route Privacy. Farmland views. Commercial exposure. As they say: Location. Location. Location. And this property has it all - history, structure, visibility, and potential. Motivated seller. Updates being done and electric being installed.

7715 US Highway 20, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Tammy Silvestri-Putnam with BETTER SPACES REALTY
L13.08 Co Hwy 35, Cooperstown
$139,000
11579874 MLS
Located in the Town of Middlefield, this ±10.01 Acres property offers rolling open land, woods, and ±200' on Cherry Valley Creek with a swimming hole. ±388' road frontage on County Highway 35. Cherry Valley-Springfield Schools. Deed restrictions apply. Electric and Broadband internet available. A perfect place to build your new home.

L13.08 Co Hwy 35, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Patricia Bensen-Ashley with ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY
L 40.11 Armstrong Rd & Co Hwy 28, Cooperstown
$89,000
11570357 MLS
A rare find in a sought-after Pierstown setting - this ±8.64-acre countryside lot presents a rare opportunity just a few miles from Cooperstown and Otsego Lake. Offering open meadows, woodland edges, and an open space area in the Otsego Land Trust. This is an ideal setting to build your country home or retreat in a location celebrated for its scenic views, gentle elevations, and easy access to historic Cooperstown, vibrant arts, and outdoor recreation. Access to electric, and high-speed internet. Cooperstown School District. There are two adjacent lots available for $89,000 each, with the option to purchase all three lots for $249,000, offering both flexibility and value for those seeking to create a legacy property or expansive getaway. Experience the best of upstate living-space to roam, nature at your doorstep, and all the conveniences of modern life.

L 40.11 Armstrong Rd & Co Hwy 28, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Patricia Bensen-Ashley with ASHLEY CONNOR REALTY

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!