Refine Search
Sort by
$220,000
R1480809 MLS
98.41 acres of prime sloping mature hardwood forest . This accessible acreage is a classic recreational and timber property located just outside Cooperstown, Otsego County. Excellent deer, turkey, and small game hunting with the beautiful creek meandering through adding to the outdoor space. Borders mature woodlands full of deer and turkey. Located 3 1/2 hours from the George Washington Bridge in NY. New Gravel Driveway, Electric, Well, Cable and High speed internet all ready at the at a nice building site. There is trails throughout the property great for Camping, Hiking, Riding and Hunting. Spectacular views and creek. 1 mile from Ommegang Brewery. Recently selectively logged with additional timber value in a few years. The property was surveyed in 2020 well marked boundaries.178.00-2-12.52 and 179.00-1-22.00

438 County Highway 33, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Benson Agency Real Estate LLC. Contact: (607) 435-9839

Selling Office: .

$260,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1533153 MLS
A long tree-lined driveway leads you to this grand contemporary 3-bed, 2-bath home on over 13ac overlooking miles of rolling hills & Susquehanna River valleys. Home features a bright country kitchen w/ SS appliances, plenty of cabinet & counter space & island, formal dining room, large living room, enclosed front porch & primary bedroom w/ walk-in closet, ensuite bath w/ soaking tub & walk-out to back deck w/ stairs leading to large landscaped yard w/ a garden & fruit trees. Radiant heat floors throughout 1st floor, newer roof. 2-car detached garage & 2 sheds offer plenty of storage space. Home is within 4.5mi of Basswood Pond & Hartwick State Forests, just 10 miles to Canadarago Lake, one of the cleanest & clearest lakes in the state, 10 miles to Cooperstown, less than 25mi to Oneonta

295 Hovick Road, Burlington

Listing courtesy of Country Boy Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: Oneonta Realty, LLC.

$710,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ R1519841 MLS
Walk to Historic Doubleday Field & Baseball Hall of Fame 2-for-1 package, 1840 Georgian Cooperstown home AND 2021 2-bedroom 1.5 bath LUXURY apartment. Fully updated INCOME POTENTIAL! Renew AirBNB permit, live on premises, rent rooms short term: ask agent for details. MAIN HOUSE w covered front porch that overlooks Cooperstown's Chestnut Street – protected w Snowball Hydrangea Standards! Parlor w kitchenette, grand center hall w period details leads to sitting room/office/dining room. Open floor-plan kitchen, breakfast nook & family room centered on brick fireplace. Kitchen reimagined w all-Maytag appliances, new HAIER refrigerator. Laundry room & mud room.1st FLR PRIMARY BDRM w WIC, & quartz & tile ba. 2nd Floor: 3 bdrms & 2 bas. Updates incl quartz & tiled bthrms, hard wood floors, AC/heat split units. Paved driveway. 2021 LUXURY apartment w 2 bdrms, .5 ba off kitchen & 1 full ba w freestanding tub + standing shower set in 12x24 marble tile. GE SS kitchen open to living room w stacked laundry in rear closet. Large closets. Private deck overlooking year-round Willow Creek.

52 Chestnut Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0470

Selling Office: Stack-Page Properties LLC.

$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1536002 MLS
Be at home in Baseball's Backyard. Literally. Become part of the fabric of quaint, historic Cooperstown...with it's one traffic light, friendly shops and restaurants and glorious Glimmerglass. This unique 2116 Sq. Ft., 3BR Victorian home is ideally located within walking distance to nearly everything that Cooperstown has to offer. Not your Grandma's Victorian home...enjoy an unexpected modern vibe with the addition of cool European radiators and exposed copper plumbing. Dramatic lighting in the kitchen enhances the original built-ins and retro-chic colorful floor. You'll enjoy spacious and brightly lit rooms with original wood details and flooring and radiant heat on the first floor. Recent updates include, replacement windows and window treatments throughout, paved driveway, a poured concrete floor in the basement, new sidewalks and porch steps. What a treasure to have, world-famous Double Day Field, in your backyard. You'll want to cheer along with diehard fans on those days when Cooperstown becomes fully alive. There's no place like it! Do not wait to see this home.

17 Susquehanna Avenue, Otsego

Listing courtesy of BlueSky Properties. Contact:

Selling Office: Non Member Office.

$650,000
R1503159 MLS
RARE Otsego Lakefront property!! Location, Location, Location!! Off of State Highway 80, onto a private lane. Plenty of parking for family and guest! This 2 home scenario does need a renovation in the cottage, or take down and rebuild your dream lake home! Some TLC in the boathouse is needed, but so many possibilities are abundant through-out this perfect lakefront property! The cottage sits high above the boathouse, waiting for a new life! The bones of the boathouse are in good shape, so you can live comfortable, while your dream house or remodel is being completed. The boat house has a double bay, plenty of room for a boat, waverunners, kayaks, etc... The rustic living quarters include 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, open kitchen, dining room, living room, with a sweet loft for kids to sleep and play games. There is no central heat , but many possibilities for upgrading heat and air. An expansive deck wraps around the boat house for outside entertainment or just relaxing. An easy in and out of boat docks for Winter storage. This property is being sold in AS IS condition! Inspections for your own personal knowledge is welcomed. The view from this property is GORGEOUS!!

106 Badger Lane, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Cedar Ridge Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: Cedar Ridge Realty.

$535,000
R1525850 MLS
Unparalleled property on upstate New York's Otsego Lake. Clear waters & spectacular views with 4,000+ acres of shoreline (only 50% available for residential repurchase & development) serves as the Susquehanna River’s headwaters. Charming historic Cooperstown lies at the lake’s southern end, which is home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Otesaga Hotel, Fenimore Art Museum, Farmers' Museum & Glimmerglass Opera, serving as a mecca for cultural attractions, fine dining & outdoor recreation. Nestled in Peggs Bay on the Lake's NE shore, this premier undeveloped ¾ acre rectangular lot is the last property of its kind on the lake. 100’ of unobstructed shoreline, the property has a grandfathered building/zoning status allowing for custom construction & favorable site development options. This incredible property offers limitless options to capitalize on its natural beauty, topography, lush tree coverage, perfect balance of sun & shade, & breathtaking western sunset views. Whether envisioning a private retreat or family vacation home, this is a perfect blank canvas for creating a lakeside oasis. Make your lakefront living dreams a reality in this iconic upstate NY location.

162 Peggs Bay Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 434-9538

Selling Office: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties.

$85,000
R1531672 MLS
Welcome to L32.06 Eggleston Hill Rd, Middlefield, NY, 13326 located on 27.43 acres in the beautiful Otsego County. This property offers a serene and picturesque setting that is sure to captivate your senses. The land features a gentle slope and wooded mountain views, creating the perfect backdrop for your dream home or private retreat. This expansive lot is conveniently located just 25 minutes from downtown Oneonta and 15 minutes from the charming town of Cooperstown, known for its rich history and cultural attractions. Additionally, Albany International Airport is a mere 1 hour and 20 minutes away, offering easy access to travel destinations near and far. For those who crave the excitement of city life, the Gorge Washington Bridge in New York City is just over a 3-hour drive away. Whether you envision a peaceful sanctuary surrounded by nature or a place to build your ideal getaway, this property provides the canvas for your imagination to run wild. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of the stunning landscape of Otsego County and create a lifestyle that seamlessly blends tranquility with convenience.

L32.06 Eggleston Hill Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Charlotteville Realty. Contact:

Selling Office: Charlotteville Realty.

$250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1490810 MLS
Nestled in charming Fly Creek and highly desirable Cooperstown school district lies your perfect country charmer. This beautiful and well maintained 4 bedroom, 3 bath sits on just under 9 acres. Upon entering immediately your greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that will make you feel at home with a farmhouse feel. Surrounded by the beauty of being in the country while being under 5 miles to the Village of Cooperstown. The beautiful landscaped grounds offer a sense of serenity and privacy creating the perfect backdrop for outdoor activities and entertaining. Trees and shrubs were planted with early spring color, summer and fall color interests in mind. As they mature you will see nice autumn colors. Koreanspice Viburnum has great spring fragrance. A bird watcher? Oh the birds you may see while sipping a cup of tea in the back yard - Scarlet Tanagers, Mourning Warblers, Song Sparrows, Eastern Phoebes, Purple Finches just to name a few. And if that is not enough, the purchase of this home includes a separate 3 acre building lot, granting you more possibilities and potential.

1193 County Highway 26, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

Selling Office: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties.

$175,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1489038 MLS
First time on the market is this quaint, circa 1880 farmhouse and barn, set on about 2 country acres on both sides of the town maintained, paved road. Heated with two propane stoves, this home offers 4-5 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The eat-in kitchen is minimal and features a walk-in pantry with its original built-in cupboard. With some imagination and remodeling, the attached wood shed lends itself to additional living space. Outside the lush green lawn is accented with a split rail fence, a smoke house stands alongside the milk house which shelters the drilled well. The blacktop driveway leads to the traditional red barn where horse stalls are still in place. New features are the roof and replacement windows. Step back in time in this adored home on your home search tour. Just minutes to Cooperstown and Oneonta.

292 Bissell Road, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-435-9413

Selling Office: Non Member Office.

$605,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1512755 MLS
This 4-bedroom Colonial in the village of Cooperstown offers a unique chance to own a fully renovated historic home. The house has been completely renovated from top to bottom while maintaining its original character and incorporating a modern touch. The house has brand-new plumbing, electric, heating systems, and the added luxury of radiant floor heat in the upstairs bathrooms. The practical side of modern living is covered; along with the Wi-Fi, high-speed internet ports are hardwired into every room of the house. The new owner can also choose their own custom countertops and sinks for the kitchen and bathrooms, which will be installed for free before closing! Positioned in a quiet suburban neighborhood and just a 5-minute walk from Main Street's shopping and dining, as well as the Baseball Hall of Fame, the location cannot be beaten. Beyond being a residence, this property is well-suited for a high-end rental, given its proximity to downtown, four blocks to Otsego Lake, 10 minutes to the Cooperstown Dreams Park, and just 300 feet from Doubleday Field. Don't miss this rare chance to own a fully renovated historic home in Cooperstown!

3 Elm Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (516) 974-8882

Selling Office: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties.

$1,645,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1517948 MLS
Nestled on the shores of Otsego Lake, this ultra luxe year-round haven underwent a full modern home renovation in 2021. Boasting 60’ of pristine lake frontage with a private dock and lakeside deck. The entry level opens to a gourmet kitchen with a spacious island and quartz countertops, flowing into the lavish living area with wrapping warmth from the statement gas fireplace, and onto the dining area offering panoramic views of the lake, complemented by beam ceilings and the soft glow filtering through skylights. The plush primary bedroom features an ensuite spa like bath with relaxing soaking tub, custom built-in closet, and the background sounds of gentle waves creating a harmonious escape. The lower level hosts a family room ideal for gathering, two additional bedrooms and full bath, an office space and bonus room all bathed in natural light and strategically positioned for the eyes to wander over the water. Includes a three-car garage equipped with a Tesla charging station, and fenced-in yard just off the garage. The charm of this lakeside retreat extends beyond the home, making it a lifestyle that seamlessly blends relaxation, Airbnb income potential, and Cooperstown allure.

112 Lake Shore Drive, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Four Seasons Sotheby's International Realty. Contact: 518-857-6396

Selling Office: Non MLS.

$799,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1508240 MLS
If living in a picturesque neighborhood is high on your list, then this property is a "must-see." This 4 to 5-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom colonial presents the sleek attractiveness of contemporary style. Cross the threshold into a warm welcome that includes a grand entryway. An open layout, abundant natural light throughout the home, and a wood-burning fireplace in the family room. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances and cherry cabinets. Off the kitchen is a back patio with a nicely landscaped perimeter and an in-ground pool, perfect for entertaining and play, while the dining room/living room can serve formal dinners. Upstairs, the sizeable primary bedroom includes a walk-in closet and a private bath with a walk-in shower. The other three bedrooms have ample wardrobe space and are ready to reflect your good taste in decor. The finished basement is currently used as a media room/ exercise room—additional features: First-floor laundry room, Central AC, High-speed internet. There is an Attached two-car garage and a detached 3-car garage with a large loft. This lovely home is surrounded by 8 acres with beautiful views. The location is a short drive to the Village of Cooperstown.

231 County Highway 28, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Stack-Page Properties LLC. Contact:

Selling Office: Stack-Page Properties LLC.

$336,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1485234 MLS
This unique two family home located on Main Street in Cooperstown yet with a country feel has been fully updated in the last few years. The owner's side ha 3-4 bedroom, updated 2 full baths and laundry area, remodeled kitchen featuring granite island and new appliances. The large living/dining room features original wide plank yellow pine floors. Home has all new windows, new roof, new plumbing, new furnace, new flooring throughout, exterior was recently freshly painted. The 2BD 1 bath apartment was also remodeled featuring completely remodeled bathroom and is ideal as a rental unit to pay your mortgage or incorporate it with the main apartment to create a single much larger home. This home sits on over an acre of land and fronts two roads, possible subdivision with proper permits. The private yard has a large deck for you and your family to enjoy offering a country feel but yet within walking distance of all attractions that Downtown Cooperstown has to offer. Many possibilities here! Don't miss this opportunity to own this unique property. Call today to find out more...

278 Main Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Faith Properties Il. Contact:

Selling Office: MVAR NONMEMBER.

$1,775,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1520060 MLS
Welcome to the epitome of lakefront living in Cooperstown. Situated at the heart of the village, directly on the pristine shore of Otsego Lake, this stunning waterfront home is making its debut on the market. It presents an unparalleled opportunity due to its premier location in one of America's most celebrated villages, offering over 100' of private lake frontage, a boathouse and dock. Designed and crafted to harmonize with the serenity of the lake, this home exudes contemporary flair and architectural sophistication. Soaring ceilings and stone fireplaces add to its grandeur, with complete first-floor living available. Gather in the kitchen, fireside in the living room, family room, veranda, or on the front patio, and bask in the ambiance of this tranquil lake setting. The versatile second floor features a grand fireplace and stunning balcony views, serving as the perfect retreat. After a day on the water, enjoy the sauna and shower located in the heated garage. Convenience abounds for dining, shopping, and savoring the quaint village of Cooperstown, just a stroll away. Truly, this is the rarest opportunity for the ultimate lakefront living!

2 Pioneer Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of CARE Brokerage. Contact:

Selling Office: Non Member Office.

$153,700
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ OD137436 MLS
Take a second look at this charming, newly surveyed, home on its quiet privately accessed street. A very nice village home that features a spacious and warm eat-in kitchen with plenty of storage space, a newly carpeted, cozy family room, and an updated full-size bathroom which adjoins a laundry room. The wood burning stove will warm the chilly, winter nights. A first floor bedroom compliments this home. The second floor features 2 bedrooms and additional space is available. This home features an attached single bay garage for storage/workshop or perhaps reconfigure to a mudroom entry. The fenced back yard with an above ground pool to help cool the humid days of summer with a separate fenced pet area, provides privacy. Other improvements include the exterior siding, new windows, and roof. This cozy home is within walking distance to the post office, a cafe' and a convenience store while being minutes from Oneonta and Cooperstown. The SELLERS ARE MOTIVATED-All OFFERS CONSIDERED.

3 Earls Road, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-435-9413

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Faith Properties.

$403,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1485695 MLS
Don’t miss this RARE opportunity to enjoy life on Otsego Lake! Let your cares and worries melt away on 80’ of your very own private water frontage. This historic ‘Camp Leatherstocking’ boasts 4 bedrooms and 1 bath. A screened-in front porch allows you to enjoy the lake views. With a drilled well and septic, this camp could be converted for year-round living. A set of stairs brings you down to the water; use the metal docks that come with the camp or build your dream dock. High-speed Internet. The seller is a licensed real estate salesperson. Camp Leatherstocking is ideally located under 5 miles from the Village of Cooperstown and 3 1/2 hours from New York City. Just a few short miles away are two golf courses – One of the oldest golf courses in America, Otsego Golf Course and the legendary 18-hole championship Leatherstocking Golf Course. Don't miss Cooperstown's world-renowned historic site-seeing locations such as Hyde Hall, Doubleday Field, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the Fenimore Art Museum, and the Farmers Museum. Enjoy Coopersotwns' Main Street shops and restaurants. Seller is a NYS licensed Real Estate Salesperson

6731 State Highway 80, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

Selling Office: Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties.

$260,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1507007 MLS
A Cooperstown Dream's Park Rental Favorite. Excellent rental history with $50,000 in recent updates and improvements. Fully furnished, impeccably maintained and already booking into next season. Located on the magnificent mile, just minutes from great food, family fun and all that baseball has to offer. This delightful 3BR, 2 BA home boasts lovely hardwood flooring, original tin ceilings, pool and recently updated mechanicals. Guests will enjoy cozy spaces, indoors and out, a brightly lit kitchen with vaulted ceilings and first floor laundry. You will appreciate the convenience of plenty of parking and a detached garage for storage or convert to a family game room. If looking for a great investment opportunity this one is a no brainer. This home should not be limited to a vacation rental as it would also make a fantastic home for even the most discerning buyers. There is nothing to do but move in. Do not wait to see it!

4963 State Highway 28, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of BlueSky Properties. Contact:

Selling Office: Vanda Properties, Inc.

$414,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1497175 MLS
DREAM INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY!!! LOCATED DIRECTLY across from COOPERSTOWN DREAMS PARK - this home is located just around the corner from the HEART OF COOPERSTOWN on over an acre! COMPLETELY TURN-KEY with an ESTABLISHED RENTAL HISTORY ... exterior highlights include an immaculately manicured property, attached two-car garage, private back deck (NEW 2023), & private back patio. Inside on the first floor highlights include a family room/game room w/laundry, all season sunroom, full bath w/additional laundry, MASSIVE OPEN KITCHEN (NEW CABINETS, EXQUISITE HARDWOOD FLOORS, STAINLESS APPLIANCES), large formal dining room, first floor bedroom, additional LARGE UPDATED FULL BATH, and a MASSIVE LIVING ROOM W/HARDWOOD FLOORS & FIREPLACE! Upstairs features include two large bedrooms with double closets & a kitchenette, and a THIRD UPDATED FULL BATH! To top this off there is a massive basement with heat already in place just waiting to be finished plus a NEW SEPTIC (2020). LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION!!! With established income and room to grow plus directly across from the FAMOUS COOPERSTOWN DREAMS PARK the POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS on this RARE FIND - don't hesitate!!!

4639 State Highway 28, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Benson Agency Real Estate LLC. Contact: 607-434-2078

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties.

$123,000
R1499402 MLS
IDEAL BUSINESS LOCATION! This solid commercial building , formerly Cherry Valley Hardware, is located steps from Main Street in the quaint Village of Cherry Valley. The 2,858 square feet of floor space includes over 1,500 square feet of heated work space, a 55' X 20.5' attached garage/shop with two bay doors, and an additional 8' X 25' enclosed front porch. Currently has one half bath, but plumbing in place for a second. Situated on a .68 acre lot, providing plenty of parking for employees and customers. Other features include high speed internet, a security system installed, and set up to be run off generator in the event of power loss. This clean slate is just waiting for your business to take it to the next level!

38 Genesee Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Stack-Page Properties LLC. Contact:

Selling Office: Stack-Page Properties LLC.