Cherry Valley Homes under $300,000

Cherry Valley Homes under $300,000

Welcome to Cherry Valley, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Otsego County! This charming village, rich in history and natural beauty, offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. With its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Cherry Valley is the perfect place to call home.

Known for its vibrant local culture and stunning scenery, Cherry Valley boasts an array of outdoor activities, from hiking and fishing to exploring the nearby Cooperstown area, famous for its baseball history and beautiful lakes. The village is also home to delightful local shops, cozy cafes, and a warm sense of community that makes it easy to feel at home.

For those seeking affordable housing options, Cherry Valley is an excellent choice. With a variety of homes available for under $300,000, potential buyers can find charming residences that fit their budget without compromising on quality or comfort. Whether you’re looking for a quaint cottage, a spacious family home, or a cozy retreat, Cherry Valley has something for everyone. Many of these homes feature beautiful yards, updated interiors, and the kind of character that makes a house feel like a home.

Investing in a home in Cherry Valley not only means securing a beautiful property but also becoming part of a welcoming community that values connection and togetherness. Experience the charm of Cherry Valley and discover why so many are choosing to make this enchanting village their home. Come visit today and see for yourself the incredible opportunities that await!

Newest Cherry Valley Homes under $300,000

35 Maiden Lane, Cherry Valley
$279,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1718922 MLS
Charming Colonial Farmhouse on 10+ Acres with Guest Cottage and Two-Car Garage! Welcome to 35 Maiden Lane in Cherry Valley, NY! Situated on 10+ acres, this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath Colonial-style farmhouse offers timeless character, country charm, and plenty of possibilities. Featuring three fireplaces, hardwood floors, and classic architectural details, the home offers a wonderful opportunity to preserve its original character while adding your personal touches. The inviting two-story layout provides comfortable living spaces, while the three fireplaces add warmth and charm throughout. A covered porch offers the perfect spot to relax and take in the peaceful country setting. Adding to the property’s appeal is a two-car garage and a separate cottage, offering exciting possibilities for an artist’s studio, creative workspace, guest accommodations, or potential rental income with some improvements and appropriate approvals. The 10+acre setting provides room for gardening, recreation, and enjoying the privacy of country living. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, weekend retreat, or property with additional income potential, this unique offering has plenty to explore. Conveniently located near the historic Village of Cherry Valley and a short drive to Cooperstown. A wonderful opportunity to own a classic country property with acreage, additional buildings, and endless potential!

35 Maiden Lane, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

916 Middlefield Road, Cherry Valley
$235,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1719527 MLS
Wow, the market has forced a price adjustment! Same quality but with a lower price, you really can't beat this opportunity. Enjoy the charm and history of Cherry Valley, with the renowned attractions of Cooperstown close enough for day trips. From the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum and Fenimore Art Museum to Otsego Lake, Glimmerglass State Park, local shops, and historic village streets, the area offers a wonderful blend of culture, history, and outdoor recreation. Some homes offer more than meets the eye, and this one is a perfect example. At only 38 years young, this Willowbrook by Ritz-Craft double-wide modular home is truly a home on steroids! While the home is beginning to show its age and could benefit from some updating, it has wonderful potential to shine again with a little imagination, personal touches, and vision. Set back from the road along a stone driveway, the home offers space, privacy, and plenty of possibilities. Inside are four generously sized bedrooms, an eat-in kitchen with skylights, a spacious living room with cathedral ceilings, and a primary bedroom with a private bathroom and double closets. A second bathroom serves the main living area. What sets this property apart is the attention to detail beyond what the eye can see. The ceilings feature fiberglass insulation, roof trusses are spaced 16 inches on center rather than the typical 24 inches, and the fourth bedroom was created through an addition with a new roof. Additional features include a 1,000-gallon concrete septic tank, a drilled well approximately 98 feet deep, a new well pump, and a furnace approximately three years old. The owners report good water with no sulfur odor. Huge attached two-car garage features poured concrete walls reinforced with 10-inch tied-in rebar, and a huge cellar. Huge barn has 200-amp electrical service and water, offering possibilities for hobbies, equipment, or a workshop. Set on a little over an acre, the property offers privacy and room to breathe—a wonderful setting to create your own peaceful home retreat. Enjoy the front porch, back deck, and outdoor space, with plenty of room to relax, entertain, and enjoy the surroundings.

916 Middlefield Road, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Sexton Real Estate. Contact: 315-853-3535

8 Genesee Street, Cherry Valley
$99,000
3 Beds ⋅ R1715783 MLS
19th-Century Greek Revival Village Classic – Blank Canvas Ready for Your Vision. Bring your restoration or renovation talents to life with this historic 19th-century Greek Revival home, perfectly set on a spacious, private village lot with long country views. The heavy lifting has already been completed: the structure has been fully gutted down to the studs, offering a seamless head start for a custom historic renovation or modern-farmhouse transformation. A renovated family home or a rental investment with loads of character and a nice village location. Property Highlights & Recent Upgrades: • Exterior & Envelope: Brand-new roof, new siding, and a large, newly constructed two-story addition that significantly expands the interior footprint and provides the space for a large eat in kitchen downstairs and giant primary bedroom upstairs. New engineered septic and leech field installed 2025. • Flexible Layout: Framed and ready for a customized floor plan with potential for 3 bedrooms and 2 to 2.5 bathrooms. • Main Level Vision: Designed for a light-filled, large eat-in kitchen featuring patio doors that step directly onto the sprawling, private backyard. Open plan living dining space in the historic section of the home. • Included Fixtures: Kitchen appliances, cabinets and a kitchen sink are included in the sale, ready for installation. • Detached Outbuilding: A solid, classic two-story barn offering secure two-car parking on the main level plus a dedicated workshop space and upper-level storage above. • Setting: Enjoy the quiet charm of village living paired with an expansive, serene backyard framed by pastoral views. This property combines authentic architectural roots with structural upgrades, eliminating the most labor-intensive demo phase. Simply bring your builder and your interior vision to complete the finishings and create a village family home. Contact us today to schedule a walkthrough and review the existing structure and included materials.

8 Genesee Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

7715 US Highway 20, Cherry Valley
$99,000
5 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 11598670 MLS
Many updates have been done. Electric service is installed and water is on. Back side of the house has new clapboard siding. Historic Farmhouse with Privacy, Farmland Views & Prime Commercial Exposure - 7715 Route 20, Cherry Valley NY Minutes to Cooperstown and 3 hours to NYC. Own a rare piece of American craftsmanship - a historic farmhouse (circa 1900) built with heavy wood flooring, high ceilings on every floor, and oversized timber framing that stands the test of time. Set along the iconic Route 20 and surrounded by open farmland, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy, rural beauty, and high-visibility commercial opportunity. Property Highlights • Historic Construction (circa 1900): Built with enduring materials, featuring oversized beams and solid framing that exemplify old-world quality. • Spacious Layout: 5 rooms upstairs, 3 rooms downstairs - perfect for living, working, or mixed-use development • Heavy Wood Flooring: Authentic, thick planks throughout every level - strong, beautiful, and full of character. • High Ceilings Everywhere: From the main floor to the attic, tall ceilings enhance openness and light. • Expansive Walk-Up Attic: Full-height, walkable attic ideal for storage, a studio, or future renovation. • Partial Basement: Requires a simple update - a horizontal drain or sump pump. • Solid Timber Construction: Oversized timbers throughout the structure ensure long-lasting strength. Condition and Air Quality A previous leak has been addressed. Setting & Location Set directly on Route 20, this property enjoys maximum exposure to steady highway traffic while maintaining total privacy - there are no immediate neighbors, only peaceful open farmland in every direction. This combination makes it ideal for both living and business - a truly prime advertising location where your sign or business will be seen by countless travelers every day. ️ Commercial & Creative Potential Few properties offer this much versatility. Perfect for: • A restaurant or roadside café • A shop, equipment repair, sales, or storage business • A workshop, studio, or showroom • A high-visibility advertising site - prime exposure right on a major U.S. route Privacy. Farmland views. Commercial exposure. As they say: Location. Location. Location. And this property has it all - history, structure, visibility, and potential. Motivated seller. Updates being done and electric being installed.

7715 US Highway 20, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Tammy Silvestri-Putnam with BETTER SPACES REALTY

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!