Refine Search
Sort by
$499,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1712940 MLS
Tucked away on over 9 peaceful acres in desirable Fly Creek, just minutes from Cooperstown, this contemporary country home offers the perfect combination of privacy, space and natural beauty. Open meadows, wooded areas, apple trees and scenic views create a beautiful backdrop for year-round country living. Step inside to a light-filled, open-concept living and dining area where soaring cathedral ceilings, large windows, hardwood floors and warm wood accents give the home an inviting character. A wood stove insert creates a cozy gathering space, while the bright kitchen features crisp white cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. Two bedrooms and a full bath on the main level offer convenient one-floor living options. Upstairs, the private primary suite is a peaceful retreat featuring its own balcony with serene country views and a jetted tub. An open loft overlooking the living area provides the perfect spot for a home office, reading area, or creative space. The walkout lower level, with high ceilings and its own fireplace, offers even more possibilities for additional living space, recreation, guests, a home gym, or workshop. An entire house generator auto transfer switch adds extra peace of mind. Whether you're searching for a full-time home, weekend escape, or your own private retreat near Cooperstown, this special Fly Creek property delivers the acreage, setting, character, and location that are increasingly hard to find. Cooperstown Central School District.

227 Donlon Road, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

$479,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1710846 MLS
INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY JUST MINUTES FROM COOPERSTOWN! Whether you’re searching for a potential baseball rental, second home, or spacious year-round residence, 107 County Highway 33 offers the space, location, and amenities to stand out. This well-maintained raised ranch features approximately 2,312 square feet of living space with 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, providing plenty of room for owners and guests alike. The main level offers hardwood floors, abundant natural light, a comfortable living room, dining area, and an eat-in kitchen with freestanding range, dishwasher, and refrigerator. Four well-sized bedrooms and multiple baths provide the flexibility so valuable for larger groups and extended stays. The lower level adds even more usable space, including a family room, office/flex space, and additional room with potential for guest area, hobby room, or whatever best fits your needs. Outside is where this property really shines. Enjoy a private in-ground swimming pool, spacious yard, deck, and plenty of room for summer entertaining, relaxing between games, or gathering with family and friends. A detached two-car garage provides additional parking and storage. Located just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, with convenient access to area baseball attractions, restaurants, shops, museums, and all that this popular four-season destination has to offer. With 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, generous living space, an in-ground pool, and a prime Cooperstown-area location, this property offers an exciting opportunity for an investor, second-home buyer, or full-time resident. Bring your vision and take advantage of the possibilities!

107 County Highway 33w, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

$79,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1712352 MLS
Opportunity awaits at 112 Gulf Road in Hartwick! Situated on 0.52 acres in the Cooperstown Central School District, this three-bedroom, one-bath home offers plenty of potential for an investor, first-time buyer, or anyone ready to roll up their sleeves and make a home their own. The house is a fixer-upper and will need updating and improvements, but offers good bones and a great opportunity to build equity while creating a space that fits your style. The property also includes multiple outbuildings, including a new Amish-built shed, providing useful space for storage, tools, lawn equipment, or hobbies. With a manageable half-acre lot, three bedrooms, and a convenient location within easy reach of Cooperstown, this property has the ingredients for a worthwhile renovation. Whether you’re looking for your next investment project or an affordable path to homeownership, bring your ideas and see the possibilities at 112 Gulf Road!

112 Gulf Road, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

$495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1710949 MLS
Discover the ideal Otsego County getaway or full-time sanctuary on 10+ private serene acres just minutes from Otsego Lake. Beautifully renovated and meticulously maintained over the years, this 3-bed, 2-bath residence combines modern comfort with rare functional flexibility. Creative minds and savvy investors alike will appreciate the separate 500-square-foot artist’s studio, a blank canvas ideal for a workshop, yoga space, office, or seamless conversion into a secondary rental or guest suite. Comprising four distinct parcels with over 1,100 feet of total road frontage along two roads, the property ensures privacy amidst a rolling landscape of open fields and quiet woods. Situated in an unbeatable central location, you are a quick 10-minute drive to Cooperstown’s famous attractions, shopping, and restaurants. Also only 10 minutes to water sports and lake views at Glimmerglass State Park, and 20 minutes to the renowned Glimmerglass Opera. The location makes it a standout choice for those relocating to the area for work or buyers seeking a high-yield vacation home. Already established as a proven, lucrative summer rental with additional potential during the peak fall foliage season, this unique property offers privacy, charm, and income-generating versatility that is increasingly hard to find.

297 Skillen Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-267-3166

$529,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1709579 MLS
Set on 29.83 private acres just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect combination of privacy, comfort, and convenience. Built in 2017 and thoughtfully updated, this home truly comes with no to do list, simply move in and enjoy. The property is surrounded by established perennial gardens and peaceful countryside, creating a wonderfully secluded setting while still being just minutes from everything Cooperstown has to offer. Elsewhere on the nearly 30 acres is a separate rustic cabin-style structure, ready for someone to finish and make their own. Its special location offers beautiful views toward Otsego Lake and even provides a unique vantage point for watching Springfields Fourth of July fireworks in the distance. Less than a mile to Glimmerglass State Park great for hiking, biking and swimming! Impeccably cared for and surrounded by nature, this special property offers nearly 30 acres of privacy, beautiful grounds, additional possibilities, and the rare opportunity to enjoy a secluded country setting just minutes from Cooperstown.

386 Springfield Hill Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

$275,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1707789 MLS
Say hello to 27 Maple Avenue, where architectural character, generous living spaces, flexible rooms, and exceptional storage come together in the historic Village of Cherry Valley. Upon entering, you will notice the home’s inviting layout and impressive staircase, which creates a beautiful focal point while leading to the second floor and its large bedrooms. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of room to gather, while separate living and family rooms provide flexibility for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a dedicated home office. The first floor also features a convenient washer and dryer setup and the beginnings of a half bath; a sink must be installed before the space can function as a complete half bath. The sunroom, featuring a hot tub that conveys with the property, offers a wonderful place to unwind throughout the seasons. Outside, the large lot provides room for gardening, recreation, and entertaining. The oversized garage is a standout feature, complete with designated workbenches, an attached equipment shed, and a loft offering additional storage or the potential for a fun hangout space. Located in the Cherry Valley-Springfield Central School District, the property is approximately 1.5 miles from the district’s Pre-K–12 campus. Enjoy convenient access to Route 20, Cooperstown, Sharon Springs, Bassett healthcare facilities, and Cherry Valley State Forest. While a home’s aesthetics can always be updated, its location cannot—and this property offers a wonderful opportunity to personalize a spacious home in a charming and historically rich community. A few thoughtful cosmetic updates could make a significant difference, allowing the next owner to highlight the home’s character and create a space that truly reflects their style. With an appealing layout, room to spread out, and storage that is difficult to find, 27 Maple Avenue is ready to welcome its new owners.

27 Maple Avenue, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Sexton Real Estate. Contact: 315-853-3535

$359,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11947527 MLS
Welcome to 217 Allison Road, a well-kept 2017 ranch offering comfortable one-level living in a peaceful Fly Creek setting. Situated on 2.56 acres, this three-bedroom, two-bath home provides approximately 1,500 square feet of thoughtfully arranged living space. The bright interior features crown molding, ceiling fans and generously sized rooms, including a spacious primary bedroom with a private full bath. The kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, substantial storage and stainless-steel appliances, while a water-softening system adds everyday convenience. Outside, enjoy the 272-square-foot covered porch and the privacy of a country property. A detached 540-square-foot garage provides additional parking, storage or workspace. Located in the Cooperstown Central School District, this inviting home offers the ease of newer construction, manageable single-story living and a quiet rural atmosphere, all just a short drive from the conveniences and attractions of the Cooperstown area.

217 Allison Road, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Natasha Selover with Stack-Page Properties

$549,000
7 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1707885 MLS
Fully renovated village home in the heart of Cooperstown with a rare bonus: a self-contained 3-bedroom accessory apartment upstairs with its own entrance and proven income history. The 4-bed, 2-bath main home spans the first floor and finished walk-out lower level - an open kitchen, dining, and living space runs the width of the house, with new cabinets, island, countertops, and appliances, and a primary bath rebuilt from the studs: tiled glass shower with rainfall head and body jets, heated mirror, heated towel rack, and all-new plumbing. Brand-new metal roof, new oil tank, replaced sewer line, new baseboard heat upstairs, refinished original floors, new LVP and carpet, fresh paint, lighting, and trim throughout. Front yard regraded; releveled, fenced back yard with play, firepit, and garden areas. Income history: long-term rentals averaging $2,200/mo and summer short-term seasons (June-September) averaging $35,000- $40,000. A short stroll to Main Street, the Baseball Hall of Fame, Doubleday Field, Bassett Medical Center, Cooperstown Central School, and Otsego Lake.

17 Walnut Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of The Greene Realty Group. Contact: 888-278-5840

$267,800
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1706975 MLS
Step into the charm of 1900 with this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-full-bath home in the Town of Springfield, where the craftsmanship and character of a turn-of-the-century home remain beautifully evident. Wide-plank wood floors, traditional divided-light windows, substantial wood trim and baseboards, and a classic wood staircase create an authentic sense of place and showcase the materials and craftsmanship associated with homes of the era. These architectural details give the home a genuine connection to its history, while thoughtful updates provide the comfort and functionality today's buyer is looking for. Offering 1,608 square feet of living space, the home features two bedrooms, two full bathrooms, an office, and a versatile bonus room. The vaulted sunroom/living room is a standout feature, with a dramatic wood-plank ceiling, warm natural light, and expansive sliding glass doors that open to the back deck. This inviting space provides an easy connection between indoor and outdoor living, creating a wonderful setting for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying the surrounding scenery. The property has received several new improvements, including new fuel oil tank, new sink, new refrigerator, painting throughout, and a water filtration system. Located directly across from the community park, this home offers the charm and convenience of small-town living while being just 15 minutes from Cooperstown and only minutes from the Springfield Public Landing on Otsego Lake. As a property owner in the Town of Springfield, enjoy access to Otsego Lake through the Springfield Public Landing, a local amenity offering opportunities for boating, swimming, and enjoying one of the region's most iconic lakes. A distinctive opportunity to own a piece of Springfield history while enjoying meaningful updates, flexible living space, a wonderful indoor-outdoor living area, community amenities, and easy access to Cooperstown and Otsego Lake.

126 County Highway 29a, Springfield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-435-4238

$569,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11906718 MLS
Village Living at Its Best - Just Moments from Leatherstocking Golf Course Perfectly situated on one of Cooperstown's most desirable tree-lined streets, 46 Nelson Avenue offers the best of Village living. Enjoy an easy walk to the renowned Leatherstocking Golf Course at The Otesaga Resort Hotel, recently recognized by USA TODAY's 10Best as the nation's #2 public golf course for the second consecutive year. You'll also love being just minutes from the Saturday farmers' market, charming boutiques, restaurants, Bassett Hospital and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Originally built in 1902, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial combines timeless character with thoughtful modern updates. Recent improvements include two tastefully renovated bathrooms, refreshed interior finishes, hardwood floors, soapstone kitchen countertops, and newer appliances, creating a home that's ready for you to move right in. The enclosed front porch, wrapped in windows, provides a welcoming place to relax before stepping into the spacious living room featuring crown molding and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. A first-floor bedroom and adjacent full bath offer excellent flexibility for guests, a home office, or one-level living. Additional highlights include a bright three-season sunroom with newer Pella windows, a detached garage, private driveway, and a full walk-up attic offering abundant storage or future possibilities. Move-in-ready Village homes with this combination of charm, updates, and location are a rare find. Don't miss the opportunity to make this exceptional Cooperstown home your own schedule your private showing today.

46 Nelson Ave, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Linda Flynn with Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

$169,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1701696 MLS
Are you looking to downsize or find a comfortable one-level home with acreage, views, and your own pond? This well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath singlewide sits on 5+ scenic acres, just minutes from Cooperstown and within the Milford School District. A detached oversized 2-car garage adds value and space. The home features a sun-filled eat-in kitchen with additional counter seating, opening directly into the living room with access to a large back deck overlooking the yard and pond. Down the hall are two bedrooms and an updated full bath. With double-pane windows throughout, the home is move-in ready. Outside, you’ll find a storage shed and an oversized garage that includes two heated, insulated rooms with electric—ideal for a workshop or craft room. The property offers beautiful mountain and pond views, a spacious backyard, and plenty of room for gardening, entertaining, and enjoying the outdoors. A wonderful opportunity for anyone seeking a peaceful, move-in-ready home with room to grow.

304 Cooper Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: 607-376-2279

$450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1701562 MLS
Own your piece of Otsego Lake and experience the best of Cooperstown living. Imagine the possibilities with this Lake Home owned by the same family for over 42 Years! The lakefront side has 50 Feet of PRIVATE LAKEFRONT, with a boathouse, private modern dock and new stairs down to the lake. This home has a rich past. Originally a 1920's fishing camp and thoughtfully expanded with a second story added in 1989. Four bedrooms all with stunning lake views, 2 1/2 baths. On the first floor, Enjoy breathtaking lake views from the open-concept living room and kitchen. The first floor bedroom has views of the lake. Full bath by the primary bedroom. and a half bath off of the kitchen. Upstairs, you'll find three more bedrooms and a full bath. The home is equipped with its own drilled well, a lake-protecting septic system with a 2500 gallon holding tank (1989) Pumped summer 2024 UPGRADES INCLUDE: *BRAND NEW SECOND STORY ROOF, (2024) *BACK WALL EXCAVATED, SEALED, NEW GUTTER ON LOW BACK ROOF, (2024) *INTERIOR FRESHLY PAINTED, (2024) *NEWLY CONSTRUCTED STAIRS TO LAKE, AND SMALL DECK, (2024) *MAIN HOUSE STAIRS REBUILT, (2024) *NEW WATER HEATER 2023, *STONE CRIB RETAINING WALL IN SOLID CONDITION. Enjoy the fenced yard for pets and children. This is more than just a home, it's a legacy property that is waiting for its next owner to love it just as much. Lakefront opportunities at this price that give you direct access to Otsego lake are becoming increasingly rare. Bring your vision, add your personal touches, and create a lakeside retreat that your family and friends will enjoy for generations. Don't miss this chance to invest in the Otsego Lake lifestyle! Spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, or simply relaxing by the water. Create the waterfront getaway you've always envisioned. Ideally located just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, you'll enjoy championship golf at the Otesaga Resort Hotel, world renowned performances at the Glimmerglass Festival, visit the Fenimore Art Museum and The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, exceptional restaurants, and everything that makes Cooperstown a destination loved by visitors year-round.

6691 State Highway 80, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna. Contact: 607-434-7436

$569,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1699374 MLS
Village Living at Its Best – Just Moments from Leatherstocking Golf Course Perfectly situated on one of Cooperstown's most desirable tree-lined streets, 46 Nelson Avenue offers the best of Village living. Enjoy an easy walk to the renowned Leatherstocking Golf Course at The Otesaga Resort Hotel, recently recognized by USA TODAY's 10Best as the nation's #2 public golf course for the second consecutive year. You'll also love being just minutes from the Saturday farmers' market, charming boutiques, restaurants, Bassett Hospital and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Originally built in 1902, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial combines timeless character with thoughtful modern updates. Recent improvements include two tastefully renovated bathrooms, refreshed interior finishes, hardwood floors, soapstone kitchen countertops, and newer appliances, creating a home that's ready for you to move right in. The enclosed front porch, wrapped in windows, provides a welcoming place to relax before stepping into the spacious living room featuring crown molding and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. A first-floor bedroom and adjacent full bath offer excellent flexibility for guests, a home office, or one-level living. Additional highlights include a bright three-season sunroom with newer Pella windows, a detached garage, private driveway, and a full walk-up attic offering abundant storage or future possibilities. Move-in-ready Village homes with this combination of charm, updates, and location are a rare find. Don't miss the opportunity to make this exceptional Cooperstown home your own.

46 Nelson Avenue, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (607) 435-0014

$195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11882750 MLS
Investment Opportunity Near Cooperstown Dreams Park! Located on a quiet country road just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown and Cooperstown Dreams Park, this seasonal two-family home offers outstanding potential for investors, entrepreneurs, or buyers looking to restore a proven income-producing property. Situated on 0.59 acres, the home features two separate units, each offering 2 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. The kitchens and bathrooms have already been updated, providing a great starting point for the next owner to bring this property back to its full potential. Previously operated as a successful Cooperstown Dreams Park rental, each unit generated approximately $1,000 per week during the baseball season. With some repairs, cosmetic improvements, and a little sweat equity, this property has the opportunity to become a strong seasonal investment once again. Outside, you'll find a spacious deck (currently in need of repair), a level .59 acre yard, and a convenient storage shed for lawn equipment and seasonal items. The property is being sold as a seasonal residence. There is no heat source, and the insulation is unknown, making it ideal for seasonal occupancy or for buyers interested in making additional improvements at a competitive Cooperstown entry level price.

597 Greenough Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC

$749,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 11878302 MLS
A Private Cooperstown Estate with Historic Elegance Just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, this beautifully restored Victorian estate offers an exceptional blend of historic character, thoughtful updates, and unmatched privacy on just under 40 acres of rolling fields, mature woods, and scenic trails. Original architectural details shine throughout, including soaring ceilings, elegant formal rooms, bay windows, dual staircases, spacious bedrooms, and inviting covered porches that perfectly capture the peaceful country setting. Extensive renovations have already been completed, including a new architectural roof, rebuilt porches and chimney, foundation repairs, updated siding, new gutters, basement and attic windows, new appliances, water softening and filtration systems, new furnace, stainless steel oil tanks, underground electric service, and updated interior and exterior lighting. The impressive restored post-and-beam barn features a rebuilt foundation, rebuilt interior floor, repaired siding and original doors, new windows, a metal roof, gutters, and fresh paint. A newly constructed, fully insulated two-car garage with a concrete floor, floor drain, and metal interior completes the property. The land is equally impressive, offering cleared trails, nearly a quarter-mile of new fencing, gated entrances with lighting, newly planted blue spruce trees, and endless opportunities for hiking, horseback riding, hunting, ATV adventures, or simply enjoying your own private retreat. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, luxury getaway, equestrian property, family compound, or investment opportunity, this remarkable estate offers endless possibilities just minutes from the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers' Museum, Glimmerglass Festival, Otsego Lake, golf, dining, and everything Cooperstown has to offer. A truly one-of-a-kind property where timeless beauty, exceptional craftsmanship, and an unbeatable location come together.

144 Pete Hendricks Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Linda Flynn with Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

$171,000
11871167 MLS
Tucked along Hinman Road in Cooperstown, this 34-plus acre property offers a rare stretch of rolling, wooded land in the heart of Otsego County. Here, you'll find the freedom to build the rural life you have been picturing, whether that means a seasonal camp among the trees, a working farmstead, or simply a private piece of upstate New York to call your own. The mixed timber and open acreage give the land natural variety, with room enough to clear space for a home site, cultivate open ground, or leave sections wooded and wild. It is a property built for flexibility, whether your plans lean toward hunting and outdoor recreation or a more settled homestead. Quiet and private, the land offers sweeping views across the New York countryside. Mornings here begin with birdsong rather than traffic, and evenings close out under skies free of city light, with the stars taking center stage. The property falls within the Cherry Valley Springfield School District and sits just 6.5 miles from downtown Cooperstown, home to Main Street's shops and restaurants and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Bassett Medical Center is 6.3 miles away, and Cooperstown Dreams Park is 10.7 miles out, keeping everyday conveniences and local attractions well within reach. For anyone drawn to outdoor life, whether that's hunting, hiking, gardening, or simply having room to spread out, this Otsego County parcel offers a blank canvas in one of upstate New York's most storied regions.

L14.01 Hinman Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Kevin Lucero with CHARLOTTEVILLE REALTY

$171,000
R1696198 MLS
Tucked along Hinman Road in Cooperstown, this 34-plus acre property offers a rare stretch of rolling, wooded land in the heart of Otsego County. Here, you'll find the freedom to build the rural life you have been picturing, whether that means a seasonal camp among the trees, a working farmstead, or simply a private piece of upstate New York to call your own. The mixed timber and open acreage give the land natural variety, with room enough to clear space for a home site, cultivate open ground, or leave sections wooded and wild. It is a property built for flexibility, whether your plans lean toward hunting and outdoor recreation or a more settled homestead. Quiet and private, the land offers sweeping views across the New York countryside. Mornings here begin with birdsong rather than traffic, and evenings close out under skies free of city light, with the stars taking center stage. The property falls within the Cherry Valley Springfield School District and sits just 6.5 miles from downtown Cooperstown, home to Main Street's shops and restaurants and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Bassett Medical Center is 6.3 miles away, and Cooperstown Dreams Park is 10.7 miles out, keeping everyday conveniences and local attractions well within reach. For anyone drawn to outdoor life, whether that's hunting, hiking, gardening, or simply having room to spread out, this Otsego County parcel offers a blank canvas in one of upstate New York's most storied regions.

L14.01 Hinman Road, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Charlotteville Realty, LLC. Contact: 607-282-6242

$220,000
R1697125 MLS
Nearly 60 acres of land in the highly desirable Fly Creek area. This unique parcel features a cleared area at its entrance, expanding into a mature, wooded hillside with additional clearings throughout. At its entrance there is electric available and a storage shed in place for the tools and toys. As the property expands up the hillside you will find an extensive trail system in place. Take the trail through the pine forest to a large clearing with mature apple trees and an older pond site that is just waiting to be reclaimed. Further on your travels you’ll find mature hardwood stands including some impressive ash and maple trees. Across the upper ridge multiple acorn producing oaks can be found with abundant signs of wildlife. Situated on a paved county road, surrounded by several larger parcels, this diverse tract of land offers potential building options and timber revenue. Secluded and private, this forested area would be a true getaway for the outdoor enthusiast, avid hunter, or land investor. Only 5 miles from the village of Cooperstown, and minutes from area attractions including the Baseball Hall of Fame, historic Otsego Lake, Cooperstown Dreams Park, and the Fly Creek Cider Mill. Come take a look at this versatile property that mother nature has created!

County Highway 26, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Benson Agency Real Estate LLC. Contact: (607) 435-3921

$195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1693062 MLS
Investment Opportunity Near Cooperstown Dreams Park! Located on a quiet country road just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown and Cooperstown Dreams Park, this seasonal two-family home offers outstanding potential for investors, entrepreneurs, or buyers looking to restore a proven income-producing property. Situated on 0.59 acres, the home features two separate units, each offering 2 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. The kitchens and bathrooms have already been updated, providing a great starting point for the next owner to bring this property back to its full potential. Previously operated as a successful Cooperstown Dreams Park rental, each unit generated approximately $1,000 per week during the baseball season. With some repairs, cosmetic improvements, and a little sweat equity, this property has the opportunity to become a strong seasonal investment once again. Outside, you'll find a spacious deck (currently in need of repair), a level .59 acre yard, and a convenient storage shed for lawn equipment and seasonal items. The property is being sold as a seasonal residence. There is no heat source, and the insulation is unknown, making it ideal for seasonal occupancy or for buyers interested in making additional improvements at a competitive Cooperstown entry level price.

597 Greenough Road, Hartwick

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

$649,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 11863463 MLS
BACK ON THE MARKET! NO FAULT OF THE HOME! Tucked at the end of a private road, this extraordinary 43.92-acre property is a place where nature, craftsmanship, and 6 decades of devotion join harmoniously together. Purchased as raw land and thoughtfully built upon, this cherished homestead reflects a lifetime of love, family, hard work, and a collection of treasures. Every path, garden, and gathering place tells a story. Encompassing meadows, mature woods, winding trails, a peaceful pond, a year-round stream, established gardens, and even a contemplative labyrinth, this homestead offers endless opportunities to explore, create, and connect with the land. The fertile acreage provides beauty and abundance. The woodlands have remained un-harvested for more than fifty years, allowing a mature forest ecosystem to flourish, offering privacy, wildlife habitat, and long-term value. Here, the soundtrack to daily life is wonderfully simple-the songs of birds and the gentle whisper of wind through the trees. The heart of the property is a solidly built log home, rich with warmth, character, and open appeal. Inside, you'll find four generous bedrooms, two spacious family rooms, a wood stove, a dining room, dedicated office, one full bath and one half bath, exposed beams, and beautiful wood floors throughout. The full basement includes a unique greenhouse/artist studio and abundant storage. Outside, a wraparound covered porch invites you to slow down and take in the beauty that surrounds you. Whether tending the gardens, wandering the trails, enjoying quiet moments beside the pond, or sharing meals with loved ones while overlooking the fields, you'll feel the deep sense of care that has shaped this property. Despite its peaceful seclusion, this exceptional offering is just minutes from Cooperstown. A truly special opportunity to own fertile, beautiful land and a lovingly crafted home in one of Central New York's most desirable locations. Rarely does a property offer such privacy, natural beauty, and character-a place lovingly created from the ground up, where a lifetime of memories has been made and where countless more await.

208 Pottery Ln, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC

$649,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1692982 MLS
A Cooperstown-Area Sanctuary on 43.5 Acres BACK ON THE MARKET, NO FAULT OF THE HOME Tucked at the end of a private road, this extraordinary 43.92acre property is a place where nature, craftsmanship, and 6 decades of devotion join harmoniously together. Purchased as raw land and thoughtfully built upon, this cherished homestead reflects a lifetime of love, family, hard work, and a collection of treasures. Every path, garden, and gathering place tells a story. Encompassing meadows, mature woods, winding trails, a peaceful pond, a year-round stream, established gardens, and even a contemplative labyrinth, this homestead offers endless opportunities to explore, create, and connect with the land. The fertile acreage provides beauty and abundance. The woodlands have remained un-harvested for more than fifty years, allowing a mature forest ecosystem to flourish, offering privacy, wildlife habitat, and long-term value. Here, the soundtrack to daily life is wonderfully simple—the songs of birds and the gentle whisper of wind through the trees. The heart of the property is a solidly built log home, rich with warmth, character, and open appeal. Inside, you'll find four generous bedrooms, two spacious family rooms, a wood stove, a dining room, dedicated office, one full bath and one half bath, exposed beams, and beautiful wood floors throughout. The full basement includes a unique greenhouse/artist studio and abundant storage. Outside, a wraparound covered porch invites you to slow down and take in the beauty that surrounds you. Whether tending the gardens, wandering the trails, enjoying quiet moments beside the pond, or sharing meals with loved ones while overlooking the fields, you'll feel the deep sense of care that has shaped this property. Despite its peaceful seclusion, this exceptional offering is just minutes from Cooperstown. A truly special opportunity to own fertile, beautiful land and a lovingly crafted home in one of Central New York's most desirable locations. Rarely does a property offer such privacy, natural beauty, and character—a place lovingly created from the ground up, where a lifetime of memories has been made and where countless more await.

208 Pottery Lane, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

$479,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 11857572 MLS
Discover the warmth and character of this beautiful 1880 Victorian home, held in the loving care of the same family for over 60 years. Tucked away on a quiet, tree-lined village street, this home offers historic integrity, incredible bones, and the opportunity to update a classic to fit your personal style. The Residence: A Solid Foundation With 4 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home has been meticulously maintained for over six decades, preserving its classic layout and architectural craftsmanship. • Hidden Treasures: Beneath the wool wall-to-wall carpeting lies original hardwood flooring waiting to be uncovered and restored to its full glory. • Bring Your Vision: While the home has been impeccably cared for, the kitchen and bathrooms are ready for modern updates, giving you the rare chance to design your dream spaces within a historic framework. A Private Backyard Haven Step outside into a wonderfully private outdoor space, completely enclosed by an 8-foot fence. • 60-Year Established Gardens: A lush, mature landscape featuring decades of curated perennial plantings. • Bluestone Patio: A 375 sq. ft. raised bluestone patio offers a solid, spacious footprint for family barbecues, outdoor dining, and relaxing in the shade. The Historic Carriage Barn A standout feature of the property is the Historic Carriage Barn. Completely intact and rich with original 19th-century details, with your vison, it could a dream space for a workshop, studio, or extra storage. Features include: • Beautiful original wainscot paneling • Turned newels in the stable area • An authentic hay loft, wash stall, and tack room A Beloved Family Home Ready for Its Next Chapter Opportunities to find a home with this level of long-term care, privacy, and original detail are rare. Bring your design ideas and make this village classic your own. Schedule a tour today!

18 Eagle St, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC

$479,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1691777 MLS
Discover the warmth and character of this lovely 1880 Victorian home, meticulously maintained by the same family for over 60 years. Tucked away on a quiet, tree-lined village street, one of the very few with no thru traffic, this home offers historic integrity, incredible bones, and the opportunity to update a classic property at a reasonable cost. The Residence: A Solid Foundation With 4 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home has been meticulously maintained for over six decades, preserving its classic layout and architectural craftsmanship. The first floor bedroom can easily transition into a primary suite allowing the ease of one floor living. • Hidden Treasures: Beneath the wool wall-to-wall carpeting lies original hardwood flooring waiting to be uncovered and restored to its full glory. • Bring Your Vision: While the home has been impeccably cared for, the kitchen is ready for modern updates, giving you the rare chance to design your dream spaces within a historic framework. A Private Backyard Haven Step outside into a wonderfully private outdoor space, enclosed by an 8-foot fence. • 60-Year Established Gardens: A lush, mature landscape featuring decades of curated perennial plantings. • Bluestone Patio: A 375 sq. ft. raised bluestone patio offers a solid, spacious footprint for family barbecues, outdoor dining, and relaxing in the shade. The Historic Carriage Barn A standout feature of the property is the Historic Carriage Barn. Completely intact and rich with original 19th-century details, with your vison, it could a dream space for an ADU, workshop, studio, or extra storage. Features include: • Beautiful original wainscot paneling • Turned newels in the stable area • An authentic hay loft, wash stall, and tack room A Beloved Family Home Ready for Its Next Chapter Opportunities to find a home with this level of long-term care, privacy, and original detail are rare. Bring your design ideas and make this village classic your own.

18 Eagle Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

$105,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1691108 MLS
Just 10 minutes from the heart of Cooperstown and 25 minutes to Oneonta, this 7.1-acre parcel offers an exceptional blend of open meadows, wooded acreage, and 425 feet of private frontage along the Susquehanna River. With mountain views, a full survey, and year-round access, the property is well-suited for building your dream home, creating a private retreat, or securing a strong investment opportunity. Super low taxes and a highly desirable location make this an attractive purchase in a region known for tourism, recreation, and long-term growth. Whether you’re fishing, launching a kayak from your own riverbank, enjoying the mountain views, or simply unwinding in nature, the possibilities are endless. Conveniently located near local craft breweries and some of the area’s most notable attractions, including the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Fenimore Art Museum, Glimmerglass Opera, and Glimmerglass State Park, as well as golf courses and scenic hiking trails, this property combines natural beauty, convenience, and investment potential in one remarkable offering.

County Highway 33, Middlefield

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties. Contact: (516) 974-8882

$850,000
R1688501 MLS
Listing $850,000. (Building Only - Tin Bin Alley is NOT Included in Sale) 114 Main Street, Cooperstown, NY Historic 1862 Main Street Row Building, Cooperstown - Mixed Use 3 Story Commercial Property with long standing rental history, and vast potential. First floor retail space is one of the largest retail spaces available on Main Street, a long history of prosperous businesses, current business spans 30 years. The 2nd and 3rd floors offer (4) long term rental apartments, three 1 bedroom, and one studio. Each floor has potential for redesigning, and rental space options. The property has had updates and renovations throughout the years, including recent rubberizing of both roofs. This Main Street property is ready for new ownership. Purchase a piece of Cooperstown history. Owner is a NYS Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

114 Main Street, Otsego

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact:

$459,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 11738090 MLS
Village living at its best! Ideally located on a quiet, tree-lined street in the heart of Cooperstown, this beautifully updated three-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath home offers the perfect blend of charm, convenience, and modern comfort. Leave the car behind and enjoy an easy walk to Main Street, restaurants, shops, schools, Bassett Medical Center, Doubleday Field, and the shores of Otsego Lake. Inside, you'll find a thoughtfully updated interior that is truly move-in ready. Bright, inviting living spaces flow seamlessly throughout the home, while modern updates provide peace of mind and allow you to settle in without a to-do list. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend retreat, or investment opportunity, this home checks all the boxes. Step outside to a beautifully landscaped yard designed for both relaxation and enjoyment. The fenced backyard provides privacy for pets, gardening, entertaining, or simply unwinding after a day in the Village. A detached garage offers additional storage and convenience. Originally built in 1910, this classic Village home retains its timeless character while benefiting from numerous updates over the years. Set on a manageable lot with public water, sewer, and high-speed internet available, it combines historic charm with everyday practicality. If you've been searching for a home that offers walkability, low-maintenance living, and an unbeatable Cooperstown location, this is one you won't want to miss.

21 Pine Blvd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Linda Flynn with Keller Williams Upstate NY Properties

$355,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 11816897 MLS
Charming 1850 Cape Cod nestled in the Hamlet of Fly Creek, New York. The period front entrance, a portico, is typical for the cape cod style house. The architectural feature consists of a small roof extending over the front door. This portico is enclosed, as is seen in the north. The formal living room has built-ins and leads to a lovely covered, private exterior terrace trimmed in perennials and annuals. The formal dining room offers a period built-in and a corner hutch. The kitchen is bright and extends into a separate office space and an oversized mudroom with laundry, pantry and rear door to the gardens and back lawn. A primary bedroom is on the main floor, with ample closet space. The first floor has the full bath with single sink and full tub/shower. The floors are original hardwood throughout. The second floor has two additional bedrooms with great closets. The potential for expansion on the second level is tremendous. A shed dormer to the north would allow for full bathroom. The property has lovely gardens and expands far to the rear with a large two-story barn. Ten minutes into the historical village of Cooperstown and all the shops, restaurants, museums and regional delights. The village is at the mouth of the Susquehanna River which empties into the Chesapeake Bay. The Glimmerglass Opera Festival is home to world renowned entertainers and events in the summer season. This home is is the Cooperstown Central School District. Walking distance to the Fly Creek Post Office, the Fly Creek General Store and the famous Fly Creek Cider Mill, still being maintained and run by the original family. Easy north commute to Utica and south commute to Oneonta. Fabulous location.

857 County Highway 26, Fly Creek

Listing courtesy of Nancy Angerer with LAMB REALTY

$235,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1688195 MLS
Nestled in the heart of the picturesque village of Cherry Valley, this inviting 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers warm character, and a lifestyle centered around comfort, community, and natural beauty. Rich natural woodwork, pretty wood floors, and French doors throughout the home create a timeless atmosphere filled with charm and craftsmanship. This sunlit home, illuminates fresh, welcoming interior spaces, highlighting the home's thoughtful details. A delightful sun porch provides a cozy space for a 2nd living room, office, or art studio. The country kitchen serves as the heart of the home, opening naturally to a formal dining room and a comfortable family room anchored by a cozy fireplace. Whether hosting friends or enjoying a quiet evening at home, these spaces create a nice circular flow for easy living. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms and an upgraded full bath, providing comfortable accommodations and peaceful retreats for family and guests. Step outside and discover a truly special backyard sanctuary. Fully fenced and carpeted with beautiful clover, the yard invites barefoot strolls, outdoor gatherings, and peaceful afternoons. A charming pond and thoughtfully designed landscape feature add beauty and tranquility, while a spacious deck surrounded by substantial stonework offers a pleasant setting for dining or entertaining. The welcoming covered front porch further extends the home's living space, offering a wonderful place to relax at day's end, greet neighbors, and enjoy the simple pleasures of village life. Located just a short 15-minute drive from Cooperstown, Cherry Valley is cherished for its quiet culture, historic character, vibrant arts community, and easy pace of living. This is an opportunity to enjoy the best of small-town charm while remaining close to the many attractions and amenities of the surrounding region. A home filled with character, light, and tranquility—perfectly suited for those seeking a wholesome and relaxed village lifestyle.

44 Alden Street, Cherry Valley

Listing courtesy of Cooperstown Brokers, LLC. Contact: