Cooperstown Real Estate

Cooperstown Real Estate

Welcome to Cooperstown, New York—a charming village nestled in the heart of Otsego County, renowned for its rich history, stunning landscapes, and vibrant community spirit. Known as the birthplace of baseball, Cooperstown is a delightful blend of small-town charm and cultural significance, making it a perfect place to call home.

As you stroll through the picturesque streets lined with historic buildings, you’ll find a plethora of unique shops, cozy cafes, and delightful restaurants that cater to every palate. The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum is a must-visit, drawing sports enthusiasts from all over the world. But Cooperstown is more than just baseball; it’s also home to the Fenimore Art Museum and the Farmers' Museum, which showcase the region's artistic heritage and agricultural history.

For those who cherish the great outdoors, Cooperstown boasts breathtaking views of Otsego Lake, where you can enjoy boating, fishing, and picnicking along the serene shores. The surrounding hills and forests offer ample opportunities for hiking, biking, and exploring nature’s beauty, particularly during the vibrant fall foliage season.

The community is tight-knit and welcoming, with various events and festivals throughout the year that celebrate local culture and traditions. Whether you’re looking to settle down in a cozy cottage or a historic home, Cooperstown offers a variety of real estate options that cater to diverse lifestyles.

Experience the magic of Cooperstown, where history meets natural beauty, and every day feels like a step back in time. Come discover your new home in this idyllic village!

Newest Listings in Cooperstown

5211 State Highway 28, Cooperstown
$1,100,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 12033804 MLS
A Home of True Distinction. Exquisitely restored to its original grandeur in 2018, this distinguished circa 1880 brick residence in Cooperstown, New York, is a rare expression of historic elegance and modern luxury. Rich in character yet thoughtfully reimagined for today's lifestyle, the home blends timeless architectural beauty with refined finishes, updated systems, and exceptional comfort. Four fireplaces lend warmth and ambiance throughout, while three beautifully appointed primary suites offer luxurious accommodations and privacy. The spacious kitchen serves as the heart of the home, perfectly suited to both intimate gatherings and gracious entertaining. A comprehensive restoration brought new life to this historic residence, incorporating all-new systems while honoring the craftsmanship and enduring appeal of its nineteenth-century origins. Set on three picturesque acres overlooking the pastoral landscape of Grasslands Farm, the property offers a captivating sense of space, serenity, and connection to the countryside. A newly constructed two-car garage adds modern convenience, and complements the home's timeless architecture. Here, historic distinction meets contemporary sophistication in one of Cooperstown's most compelling settings. More than a home, this is a bespoke lifestyle-defined by architectural heritage, understated luxury, and the pleasure of living beautifully.

5211 State Highway 28, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC
0 CR 52, Cooperstown
$399,000
12033822 MLS
Rarely does an opportunity arise to own such an expansive and beautiful tract of land. Set along a scenic county road in the Town of Middlefield, just outside the beloved village of Cooperstown, this fully wooded acreage offers a captivating natural landscape with southeast exposure and gently undulating terrain. A diverse mix of mature hardwoods and conifers creates a peaceful woodland setting, complemented by a picturesque pond tucked into the northwest corner and a meandering stream that winds through the property. Whether you envision a private recreational retreat for hunting, hiking, and enjoying the outdoors, or wish to explore the potential for residential development, this remarkable property offers an exceptional range of possibilities. Enjoy the tranquility and beauty of the countryside while remaining conveniently close to Cooperstown, its charming village center, and its many amenities. A rare opportunity to secure a substantial piece of Upstate New York's natural beauty and make it your own. **Be sure to watch the YouTube video attached to the listing!

0 CR 52, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Michelle Barry with COOPERSTOWN BROKERS LLC
206 Kraham Rd, Cooperstown
$450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 12014083 MLS
Discover the rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and close proximity to Cooperstown: a private, wooded 4.78 ac retreat just two miles from the village of Cooperstown, yet less than five minutes from the village's shops, restaurants, services, recreation, and renowned cultural attractions., This exceptional home's quiet and serene location offers easy access to everything wonderful Cooperstown has to offer. The updated, beautifully-maintained 4-5 bedroom, 2-bath Colonial offers 1,848 square feet of living space, with a floor plan that can accommodate one-level living on the first-floor or expansion in the unfinished basement , if desired. Generously sized, sun-filled rooms, hardwood floors, a formal dining room, updated kitchen and open family room with gas fireplace create a warm and welcoming interior to gather and unwind.. A new roof in 2024, a tastefully remodeled kitchen, and two chic, stylish baths add to the home's move-in-ready appeal. The home sits beautifully in an open, level, lushly landscaped clearing. There's plenty of open lawn for play sets or outdoor recreation. The oversized rear deck takes full advantage of sweeping forest and hillside views and provides an exceptional setting for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply enjoying the peaceful sights and sounds of nature.Trails lead from the property to one of Cooperstown's iconic hillside hikes. The location is exceptional-just minutes from Glimmerglass Lake, Clark Sports Center, Bassett Hospital, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Fenimore Farm and Art Museum, Glimmerglass Festival, and Cooperstown's celebrated shops and restaurants. Private, peaceful, beautifully maintained, and remarkably close to the heart of Cooperstown-this is a special opportunity to create your own Upstate New York retreat or primary home.

206 Kraham Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Joan Fox with KELLER WILLIAMS UPSTATE NY PROPERTIES
15 Pine Blvd, Cooperstown
$615,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11979452 MLS
Located on a desirable street in the Historic Village of Cooperstown, this beautifully renovated 2-3 bedroom Ranch offers 1,584 sq ft of living space on a 0.43-acre lot. Originally built in 1958, the home underwent an extensive renovation beginning in 2020 and completed in 2021, taking it down to the studs and transforming it with new plumbing, electrical, and heating and cooling systems, all-new Marvin windows, 25-year Cambridge architectural shingles, and LP SmartSide siding. New manufactured hardwood floors throughout and tiled bathroom floors. The beautifully appointed kitchen features custom-built cabinetry by a highly regarded local contractor and a large island with abundant storage. The open-concept layout seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining area, and living room. The spacious primary suite features a large accessible bath with dual sinks, a walk-in shower, and a walk-in closet. A second bedroom, additional bedroom/office, and full bath provide flexible living options. The laundry/pantry is conveniently located off the kitchen and leads to the heated, attached 1-1/2-car garage. An unfinished basement offers additional storage. Outside, enjoy the landscaped grounds, generous lawn, large covered front porch, and inviting patio surrounded by newly established perennials, ideal for quiet relaxation or entertaining. Explore Cooperstown's downtown, with excellent restaurants, unique gift shops, the year-round Cooperstown Farmers Market, a local treasure for fresh produce and artisan goods, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Nearby Otsego Lake, affectionately known as the Glimmerglass, offers boating, kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing. Enjoy golf at Leatherstocking Golf Course, which trails along the lake, and explore the Fenimore Art Museum. A short drive to Glimmerglass Festival, or discover the hiking and biking trails, fishing, picnic areas, beach, and seasonal events at Glimmerglass State Park. With its thoughtful renovation, inviting outdoor spaces, and comfortable open-concept design, this home offers modern comfort while retaining the appeal of Village living. Cooperstown's historic architecture, tree-lined streets, and vibrant year-round community create a distinctive sense of place, making this a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the character and convenience of one of Upstate New York's most treasured Villages.

15 Pine Blvd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Denise Page-LaCava with Stack-Page Properties
670 Glimmerglen Road, Cooperstown
$879,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11991448 MLS
(9833) Secluded, nearly-new 3BR/2BA country Traditional-style with panoramic vistas on 5.72 acres. Distinctive, light and airy plan two-story boasting manicured lawn, a patio, plus a large screened-in porch, gas fireplace and great room. Primary bedroom, Jack and Jill Bedrooms. 16x32 In-ground Salt water fiberglass pool. Spacious floorplan, handy pocket doors, heat-saving thermal glass, recessed lighting, custom kitchen with center island, large Rec room, main-level laundry. 24 x 34 Pole Barn. Come home to an air of comfort and welcome. 3+ miles from Cooperstown. Close to Hospital, Golf course, Museums, and shopping. Cooperstown Schools. Hubbell's Real Estate Exclusive.

670 Glimmerglen Road, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Cindy Hubbell with HUBBELLS REAL ESTATE INC
18 Main St, Cooperstown
$1,995,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 11962275 MLS
Exceptional C.1815 Cooperstown residence located on the quieter portion of Main Street, just steps from fine restaurants, unique shops, a year-round Farmers Market, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. This distinguished brick townhouse represents a rare architectural design found in upstate New York and is proudly listed on the New York State Historic Register. An award-winning restoration completed in 2008-2010 preserved the home's architectural character while updating electrical, plumbing, heating, insulation, windows, sprinkler, radon, and alarm systems, and adding an elevator. Sunlit rooms filled with natural light showcase gracious proportions and beautiful historic details. The inviting foyer features a curved staircase. The expansive kitchen offers soapstone countertops, center island, La Canche range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, pantry with two-drawer freezer, and propane fireplace, complemented by a well-appointed butler's pantry with a second dishwasher, wall oven, ice maker, and wine cooler. Also on the main floor, the living room and formal dining room, both with propane fireplaces, and a den/library with a fireplace, all provide elegant spaces for entertaining. The second floor includes a spacious primary suite with an ensuite bath and propane fireplace, two additional bedrooms-one with a propane fireplace-and a second full bath. A private third-floor suite with a full bath offers an ideal guest retreat. The finished walk-out lower level features a tavern room with a bar, wood-burning fireplace, and bake oven; a family/media room; a full bath; an indoor hot tub room; laundry; a utility room; and a mudroom with garage access. Set on 0.21 acres, the property includes a private backyard, vegetable garden, two garages-one attached is heated, and one detached-and an additional garage currently used as an exercise room. Additional features include a whole-house generator, intercom, security and sprinkler systems, acoustic speakers, propane heat with oil backup, and 28 solar panels. Otsego Lake, only a block away for boating, kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing, with Leatherstocking Golf Course, Fenimore Art Museum, Glimmerglass Festival, and Glimmerglass State Park close at hand. A rare opportunity to own a meticulously restored piece of Cooperstown history-an exceptional brick townhouse distinguished by architectural significance, craftsmanship, and privacy. This home sits in a neighborhood known for its rich history, local events, and small-town character. PLEASE VISIT OUR WEBSITE FOR THE VIDEO & 3-D TOUR.

18 Main St, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Denise Page-LaCava with Stack-Page Properties
578 Greenough Rd, Cooperstown
$420,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11971944 MLS
Built in 1850 and located in the historic hamlet of Toddsville, this 2,128-square-foot farmhouse blends original character with chic modern farmhouse style. Abundant natural sunlight fills the home, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. The first floor features a living room, which is currently used as the primary bedroom, with a 3/4 bath, an appliance-ready kitchen, a formal dining room, a pantry/laundry area, and a spacious family room. Three additional bedrooms and a full bath on the second floor. Original six-over-six windows with storms and wide-plank floors preserve the home's authentic character, while contemporary touches add a fresh, inviting feel. The current owner has thoughtfully maintained the property for well over a decade, preserving many of its original features. Set on 0.81 acres, the property offers a large private yard framed by mature trees and established perennials, along with a two-car garage. Oaks Creek runs behind the property and flows through the Greenough Road Conservation Area, offering opportunities for trout fishing, paddleboarding, and hiking along scenic trails. Just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake, restaurants, shops, and cultural attractions, this special property offers a distinctive combination of historic character, chic modern farmhouse style, and a wonderful connection to nature. High-speed internet.Cooperstown Schools.

578 Greenough Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Denise Page-LaCava with Stack-Page Properties
280 Main St, Cooperstown
$420,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11959556 MLS
Built in 2021 and located within Cooperstown Village limits, this unique home sits on a surveyed 0.52-acre lot, offering a peaceful, wooded setting while still providing the convenience of village living. As you enter the home, you're welcomed by a bright and functional atrium that could serve as a breakfast nook and or office. Inside, warm natural wood finishes, exposed beams, vaulted pine ceilings, and an open layout give the home plenty of character and charm. A spacious loft, accessed by a distinctive spiral staircase, provides additional flexible living space and includes its own full bathroom. The kitchen features an island, stainless steel appliances, and generous workspace. Radiant heat provides comfortable, even warmth throughout the home. The first-floor primary bedroom features an attached private bathroom and walk-in closet, offering convenient single-level living and a comfortable retreat. Additional highlights include a dedicated laundry area and beautiful natural woodwork throughout. Outside, the home features natural wood siding, a durable metal roof, a shed across the road with an additional parking space, mature trees, and a private yard. A great opportunity to own a newer home with rustic character and enjoy a peaceful, country-like setting on over half an acre, all while being right inside the Village of Cooperstown.

280 Main St, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Caleb Edgington with Stack-Page Properties
90 Grove St., Cooperstown
$585,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 11935481 MLS
Set on two parcels totaling 1.36 acres, this spacious Cooperstown property offers a rare combination of privacy, outdoor space, and convenient village living. Tucked away in a peaceful setting yet just a short walk from the hospital, schools, stores, and everyday amenities, the location is exceptionally practical. The approximately 2,738-square-foot, four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath home offers generous living space and the character and proportions of a classic Cooperstown residence. The property includes an attached garage with ample grounds providing flexibility for gardening, recreation, entertaining, or simply enjoying the privacy of your own space. The two-parcel configuration and 1.36-acre setting are particularly appealing in the village, offering a sense of country privacy without sacrificing the convenience of being close to everything. A welcoming wraparound porch offers the perfect place to relax and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. The private backyard is truly a peaceful garden sanctuary, featuring beautiful stone walls, a tranquil koi pond, and a charming waterfall. The soothing sound of cascading water creates a relaxing backdrop for outdoor gatherings or quiet moments in nature. Thoughtfully renovated in 2007, the kitchen combines functionality with timeless appeal. Silestone countertops provide generous workspace, complemented by a gas cooktop, wall oven, and microwave. A center island with seating creates an inviting gathering spot while offering valuable additional cupboard storage. Designed for everyday living and entertaining, this well-appointed kitchen remains a practical and welcoming heart of the home. The home's inviting layout offers a natural flow from room to room, creating an easy and comfortable setting for everyday living and entertaining. Cherry hardwood floors add warmth and character throughout the living spaces, while a new pellet stove in the living room provides an especially cozy gathering place during the cooler months. The formal dining room provides a warm and inviting space for family dinners, holiday gatherings, and entertaining. The family room opens directly to the private backyard sanctuary. It's a relaxing setting for morning coffee, gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the property's privacy. A conveniently located first-floor laundry room and half bath add to the home's livability and ease of use. Ample closet space is available throughout the home. The 2nd floor primary bedroom offers a comfortable private space, complete with its own full bathroom and a generously sized walk-in closet. Thoughtfully arranged for both comfort and convenience, the suite provides a relaxing space to unwind. One of the 3 other good-sized bedrooms upstairs offers a distinctive and versatile retreat, featuring its own private sitting area with a propane fireplace. A walkway from this space leads directly to the backyard, creating an inviting connection between the interior and the property's peaceful outdoor setting. This flexible space could easily serve as a guest suite, reading room, home office, or cozy private retreat. The home's exterior has been thoughtfully maintained, with Hardi Board cement siding and 50-year architectural shingles, both installed in 2008. These durable improvements provide lasting protection, complement the home's classic character, and reduce the need for near-term exterior updates. A substantial village property with privacy, space, and an exceptionally convenient location-just minutes from the best of Cooperstown.

90 Grove St., Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Anna Snyder with Stack-Page Properties
2396 County Highway 31, Cooperstown
$428,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 11873011 MLS
Step back in time without sacrificing modern comfort in this meticulously renovated 1860 home formerly known as the Seward house and situated near the "corners" in the hamlet of East Springfield. Standing tall on a fenced and level .42 acres, this 2,912-sq ft 2-story structure was erected with locally quarried cut and dressed large limestone blocks and set on bedrock for lasting endurance. A three-story addition completed in 1998 expanded the living space while complementing the home's original architecture. The first floor features a multi-windowed living room with new wide-plank pine floors, original deep-set 6-over-6 windows, an eat-in kitchen with ample cabinetry, a formal dining room, and a spacious family room with a Vermont Castings wood stove and half bath. A convenient first-floor laundry room is tucked behind the original door at the bottom landing of the original and wide staircase to the 2nd floor whose former use as a select school, a meeting house and a ballroom was known as Seward's Hall. The owners' 1998 renovation/restoration retains its impressive 10-foot ceilings, original wainscoting, and deep-set windows but now includes three bedrooms, a full bath and built-in shelves. At the end of the bright commodious hallway you will find adjacent original doors: one to the 1998 portion of the house where the primary bedroom has a full and updated bath, the other opening to a wide and carpeted staircase up to the top floor where you will be pleasantly surprised to find a well insulated, carpeted, finished space with 2 dormers and 5 windows, called bonus rooms, awaiting. The original 1825 post-and-lintel blacksmith shop has been transformed into an insulated two-car garage with electric heat, automatic and insulated steel doors, custom period-style windows, and additional loft storage. A separate 320-square-foot workshop with electricity, lighting, workbench, and attached firewood storage provides excellent space for hobbies or projects. Major improvements include 200 amp service, new wiring and plumbing throughout (1998), spray foam insulation to original house (1998), architectural shingle roof on the house and garage (2025-2026), 2 Hormann garage doors (2025), a 1,500-gallon septic tank (2023), exterior staining and painting of house, garage and shop(2025), updated kitchen and bathroom faucets and a new primary bath vanity (2026). Springfield Township residents enjoy exclusive access to Springfield Landing on pristine Otsego Lake, offering a private beach, swimming, docking facilities, and canoe/kayak storage. 4 miles down East Lake Road is Glimmerglass State Park with a beach, hiking trails, campsites, cross-country skiing and NY's oldest covered bridge which leads to Hyde Hall Mansion. Another 6-mile scenic drive along the lake leads you to the Village of Cooperstown where you can visit the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the Fenimore Art Museum and attend performances at the world-renowned Glimmerglass Festival. The house is strategically located near Scenic Route 20, a straight-as-an-arrow 1-hour drive to Albany. Historic homes of this quality are increasingly rare. Combining authentic history, generous living space, aesthetic updates, and an idyllic country setting near Cooperstown, this exceptional limestone home is truly one of a kind.

2396 County Highway 31, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Ryan Burns with Stack-Page Properties
113 Lake Street, Cooperstown
$650,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 11870201 MLS
Constructed around 1900, 113 Lake Street in Cooperstown, New York is a classic 1.5-story frame house retaining many of its early architectural details. Located within the Cooperstown Historic District, the property features a side-gabled roof, wood clapboard siding, and an open, shed-roofed porch supported by square posts. The house is situated on a deep 1.56-acre lot that also includes a historic detached outbuilding reputedly used as an ice house and built in 1880. The first floor offers a formal living room, a formal dining room, open eat-in kitchen, mudroom/laundry is off the kitchen, primary/master bedroom with a dressing room and full bath. The second floor has three additional bedrooms and a full bath. The front porch is sweet and has expansive views of the Leatherstocking Golf Course and breathtaking views of Otsego Lake. Over the years, the property has undergone modifications, including a shed-roofed dormer added in the early 1900s and an expanded two-story gable-roofed back primary first floor bedroom addition in 2006. At this time the kitchen was renovated and expanded and a mudroom/laundry with separate entrance was added. This historic home is being offered for the first time in forty plus years. Location, location, location.

113 Lake Street, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Nancy Angerer with LAMB REALTY
196 Cemetery Rd, Cooperstown
$275,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 11833172 MLS
Unlock the possibilities with this unique investment property featuring a charming cottage residence and an impressive 5,700-square-foot commercial workshop, all situated on one parcel. Whether you're an entrepreneur seeking a live-work setup, an investor looking to diversify income streams, or a business owner in need of substantial workspace, this property offers a combination that is increasingly difficult to find. The cottage provides comfortable residential accommodations that can serve as an owner-occupied residence, employee housing, or a rental unit generating additional income. Its manageable size and cozy character make it an attractive option for tenants seeking a peaceful place to call home. The true centerpiece of the property is the expansive 5,700-square-foot commercial workshop. Offering ample space for manufacturing, fabrication, storage, contracting operations, automotive work, woodworking, warehousing, or a variety of other commercial ventures, this versatile building presents tremendous opportunities for business growth and income generation. The large footprint allows for multiple work areas, equipment storage, inventory management, and future expansion possibilities. Located just under 4 miles from the Village of Cooperstown, don't miss this exceptional opportunity to own a property where residential comfort and commercial capability come together to create outstanding investment value.

196 Cemetery Rd, Cooperstown

Listing courtesy of Ryan Burns with Stack-Page Properties
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!